
Medical accident complaint “not considered defamation” – Manga author sues former surgeon – Osaka District Court. The author, a man, holds a press conference regarding a manga modeled after the medical accident at Akoh City Hospital (right) = afternoon on the 1st, Kita Ward, Osaka City.
漫画を買うなら楽天kobo(電子書籍)が断然オススメ!
It’s funny that Takeda-kun’s manga is decorated in a picture frame.
Is it a masterpiece?
Are you the type to make the first move?
I know a few, but it feels strange.
Was it necessary to frame it?
>>4
Provocation
>>4
But I can’t think of any way to display it other than putting it in a frame…
Is the author referring to Takeda-kun?
It’s about clear files, you know.
The author was a victim’s family member, wasn’t he?
Takeda-kun confidently said that the disclosure request was approved!! but after that, he stopped mentioning the author, didn’t he?
I was a victim…
Takeda-kun, how could you go on after killing your family?
>>10
I had a frustrating experience realizing that once someone becomes well-known on social media, any kind of person can gain followers.
>>10
Wasn’t it the family of a person who couldn’t move because they were twisted by a neural drill, not a dead person?
I thought the movements outside of the manga were like an out-of-ring brawl, but it’s starting to become the main battleground.
The manga not only surpassed the original story but became one with it.
I want you to tell me what is wrong.
>>13
It seems like it was a liquid that shouldn’t be consumed during work, not Ozack.
>>16
Is it alcohol…?
>>13
Still being involved in healthcare.
An account claiming to be Takeda-kun’s model is still spreading slander, and there are some factions supporting it, so it’s quite a frightening situation…
>>14
No matter how wicked a person is, if they are being criticized online…
I’m being bullied by a lot of people! This can’t be overlooked!
There will definitely be a contrarian like that coming out…
>>114
The problem is that the one at the forefront is the model estimation of Takeda-kun (almost certain) himself…
I have no intention of defending Takeda-kun, but I thought it might be considered defamation, though it has been avoided.
Was it the family of the victim?
It wasn’t in vain that I investigated Takeda’s misdeeds and drew a manga about it.
>>19
Well, if readers think that way (that it’s non-fiction), wouldn’t that be defamation?
>>25
So isn’t the point of the thread image’s trial to settle things once and for all?
It’s milder than reality.
If we’re talking about defamation, I can’t help but think that the colleague (or whatever) who called me “Takeda-kun” should be the first one to be addressed.
If you don’t come out yourself, there can’t be any defamation or anything like that.
I saw it on the news in the evening.
It’s usually done in the Kansai region.
https://news.yahoo.co.jp/articles/13135257b9886e9e92d0ae71242753a3d21fac69
That’s an amazing resolve.
>>24
If you intend to insist that this is a fiction unrelated to real events, rather than an accusation…
I think it’s strange that the author claims there is public interest or that it lacks truthfulness, but I don’t really understand.
Like decorating a rag with a picture frame.
>>26
It’s completely different.
If defamation is accepted, it will be acknowledged, and if it is not accepted, it will be safe since it is a fictional character.
I haven’t heard about it anymore, but has it calmed down?
Did the author raise this issue first…?
>>31
It was Takeda-kun who disclosed it first, but he suddenly became silent…
If anything, just the fact that the person has come out in front of everyone already feels like a win.
But for some reason, it’s strange.
I can’t see any further vision of Takeda-kun getting hurt.
>>34
I won’t have my medical license revoked.
>>38
The surgery is terrible, and I keep making mistakes.
It’s not like I’ve intentionally killed a patient or anything unrelated to my work as a doctor…
>>80
Didn’t the model say it was intentional?
I thought that person might do something like that in response to the family’s outrage.
Aren’t you even trying to play the role of a pitiful victim when you say things like that?
I wonder if the teachers who support us no longer intend to protect us.
There are no paperbacks, so if I want to display it, I guess I have to frame it…
A group of conspiracy theorists who support the governor of Hyogo Prefecture is also supporting Takeda-kun, and it’s quite chaotic.
>>40
Since Takeda-kun and that guy are from the same high school as Big Motor…
I want to see the expression on their face when they find out that the victim’s relatives were disclosed after all that effort.
>>42
I’m still continuing to crush it as it is, though…
>>44
As expected, it’s the real deal.
That’s not it…
There are quite a few malicious Takeda-kun who are smart but don’t show it, so I want you to do something about that too.
Taking the initiative to get the court’s approval is a good strategy.
https://dr-takeda.hatenablog.com/entry/2025/02/05/%E5%A3%B0%E6%98%8E%E6%96%87
The work itself is fiction, but it openly states that it is motivated by real medical accidents, so it can’t be said that it’s unrelated.
Although Ako City is in Hyogo, is the Osaka District Court taking action?
I don’t really understand, but I’ll click the link and read it.
Well, what a horribly bad taste absurd gag manga… I wonder why this is getting attention.
…Huh… Is there a model for this…?
It makes me nostalgic to remember that I really felt sick back then.
>>48
If the free trial periods of K2 and Koi Maho hadn’t overlapped, I think it would have been such a terrible story that I wouldn’t have been able to read it properly.
The real Takeda-kun is more impressive than in the manga.
>>49
Well, it’s easy to understand that the monster is just like in the manga.
“Being a Takeda believer is somehow…”
It’s so scary that Takeda-kun thinks it’s just a grudge, despite so many victims.
I wished the growling scene was fiction…
As long as the manga is available online, it can’t fade away, so it’s a nice method.
Even if I’m taken in urgently, I’m thinking of refusing only Dr. Takeda.
>>57
Stop the reputational harm to Takeda doctors nationwide.
>>57
I’ll write this since my name came up in the news, but my last name is Matsui…
Did you not realize in advance that going to court means there is a possibility that the obscured names will be revealed clearly…?
We have to thank Takeda-kun’s fans by having Takeda-kun perform surgery for them.
I don’t know the details of the current court situation, but wasn’t Takeda-kun unemployed now?
In reality, Mr. K doesn’t exist, but Takeda-kun does; that’s the worst, right?
There are more contrarians in the world than I thought, and they are very loud…
Takeda is a worthless surname, whether it’s a doctor or an emperor.
>>66
Just to mention, the model’s character has a different real name.
I wonder what feelings the victim’s family had when they created it.
It’s really not funny to be treated like a dirty rag.
By the time Takeda-kun was dragged into court, it was already his loss.
If you collapse in Osaka, you can meet Takeda-kun!
It’s troublesome that there is a doctor with the same name as my real name causing inconvenience.
The only relief is that they don’t come out of Kansai.
It’s Takeda-kun’s model.
I will tell you the truth.
With this, we can perfectly capture the hearts of the masses.
I hear that there are tons of doctors at Takeda-kun’s level who just don’t come to light.
>>75
It’s fine that there are people at the level of Takeda-kun, even if I concede a hundred million steps.
The failed sealing and the subsequent moves are too garbage.
>>75
Well, no matter the job, there are always some careless and crazy people out there.
Not every person involved in saving lives automatically possesses a noble spirit.
>>75
Still, usually, one can reflect on their actions or change positions.
There are very few people like Takeda-kun in the true sense.
>>75
When the manga started trending, there were doctors saying, “Oh, we have someone like Takeda-kun too, lol,” but during the nerve drill video, they were seriously saying, “No way…,” so I hope you find that reassuring.
>>75
If there were so many monsters at this level around, the healthcare system wouldn’t hold up.
>>75
Normally, it’s common to move away from surgery and get involved in other work.
In this case, it’s about someone who is incompetent but stubbornly focused on surgery without putting in effort, resulting in numerous fatalities.
If Takeda-kun were to enter the beauty industry, there would be no problem at all.
I feel like there were about two doctors with the same name.
It was sake instead of Ozak, how terrible.
Takeda and Matsui have quite the skillful evasion, huh?
It’s not even a real name.
They’re swarming, but they’re sealed or not undergoing surgery.
Takeda’s strong connections and his eagerness to perform surgeries have combined with the culture of Ako Hospital, resulting in something incredible.
From observing the reactions of several doctors, it’s common for them to have killed a few people before becoming fully qualified.
I feel a stance that if every little thing were to be sued, healthcare would not be sustainable.
I think it’s a matter of degree.
>>85
In reality, all doctors have the potential to make some kind of mistake.
Moreover, if every mistake is treated as a crime, then many doctors will say they won’t work! Also, the number of cases where doctors will refuse to perform surgeries because they don’t want to be sued will increase.
>>85
Even with the best measures taken, a doctor must accept that patients will die when it is their time; there are circumstances in which a patient’s death is unavoidable.
Takeda-kun fundamentally lacks the skills to take the best course of action.
>>85
It seems like there is no way to achieve a refreshing result because this is here.
If such a complaint were to succeed, no one would want to perform medical procedures.
Please get along well with the sparkling organ donation as you move to a different industry.
It’s terrible that they say Chocolate is better than Takeda-kun.
>>89
You can’t compare a chocolatier who is a psychopath and has medical skills with another psychopath.
>>97
But Chocolata deliberately operates on patients who don’t need surgery and makes them suffer, right?
>>101
Takeda-kun also wants to operate on patients who do not need surgery.
>>101
It’s Takeda-kun…
>>89
Chocolata is a doctor with knowledge and skills who deliberately makes patients suffer or kills them.
Takeda-kun lacks the minimum required skills and knowledge, so in that regard, he is below Chocolata.
>>89
Chocolata has skills and was a well-regarded doctor until he was found out, so it would be rude to compare him to Takeda-kun.
If there were a large number of surgery berserkers with backing, it would be way too terrifying.
It’s common for even the truth to be considered defamation, but the fact that it didn’t means there’s probably something way worse going on, to be honest.
Even Chocolata would perfectly play the role of a doctor if instructed to have surveillance by the boss…
In the first place, it’s on a different level than being unable to do it.
If the charge of negligent injury in business is upheld, it could result in a five-year prison sentence.
Please be sealed, I beg you.
The nerve drill completely transcends fiction.
It’s a way of thinking that can’t win in creation.
>>107
I wanted it to be fiction…
In America, it seems there is actually a template for suing doctors, making it easy for anyone to sue a doctor and obtain money.
The supporters of Takeda-kun should consult him when they or their family members go to the hospital!
Unless it’s a claim for damages, the only costs incurred will be for litigation and attorney fees, so that’s quite a determination.
>>112
The money hasn’t been billed and should be an outgoing expense…
I believe that manga itself has value in being framed and displayed.
I can’t do anything about what I know, but I certainly fulfilled my role in making the social issue of medical malpractice known.
Dr. Takeda, who models for the overseas explanatory videos being created.
I hope that the situation can unfold quietly without any further strange escalation.
Is this manga not monetized?
It seems there are precedents that can be accepted if there is clear negligence.
If it’s a level of negligence that is stated as unacceptable in a general medical book, then…
If it weren’t for the culture of that hospital…
I was surprised to see that they were increasing their followers one after another, thinking they had entered the market aiming for social sanctions.
Aren’t you scared?
>>123
It’s like a bug on social media where, when someone is confident, followers start to think, “For some reason, this person isn’t bad!”
>>123
Takeda-kun sometimes says convenient things depending on the situation.
It is terrifying that there are many people who support things without looking at them carefully, or who want to go against the facts just for the sake of being contrary.
In reality, if it weren’t for that manga, there would have been very few people interested in this kind of thing, so the method chosen was effective.
Other than the fact that both Chocolata, who was diligent in honing his skills until he knew the human body inside and out, and Takeda-kun, who slacked off and went fishing instead of working when he punched in, like to cut people up, there are hardly any similarities.
If the judiciary functions properly, I have no complaints at all…
Since you did it for me, I will do it for you.
It feels like a bonus game now.
If it becomes defamation, I’ll at least contribute to the cost of the manga.
It’s amazing that you strategized to create a buzz and prevent it from fading away, and you achieved certain results.
If we’re talking about kill scores, the same doctor at Gunma University Medical School has caused the deaths of 18 people in 5 years.
Both are scenes that are often used in the thread images…
To be honest, before I read the manga, I thought it looked like a strange manga just based on the thumbnails and art style, so I can’t say much bad about it.
I thought there was almost no way to legally sue someone by identifying them online… until I saw that act…
I think it’s quite amazing that it has been proven that buzz can be effective against a culture of concealment.
If it weren’t for this manga, there would still be victims today.
Until it was featured on TV, I only had the impression that the nameless person was just bringing out some strange manga and playing with it.