Home » Manga » WITCH WATCH » [WITCH WATCH] When you say that Witch Watch and Sket Dance are works from the disciple of Gorilla…

[WITCH WATCH] When you say that Witch Watch and Sket Dance are works from the disciple of Gorilla…

During high school, he worked hard on preparing for the cultural festival, and a certain manga artist discussed the cultural festival with a teacher at their workplace during their assistant days. The name is withheld, but the teacher said they hated things like cultural festivals. Don’t you get it even if the name is withheld? “Those who worked hard on cultural festival preparations and felt their youth playing in bands are looked at with cold eyes from the corners of the classroom—it’s not a lie, they just laugh.” His eyes had a color like cigarette tar. What kind of story is this? That assistant later continued to draw a manga like a late-night radio show that creates a bad vibe about working hard on cultural festival preparations. They’ve already called it a gorilla, after all.

0: Japan Otaku Reviews

The structure of the joke is extremely convincing, but the difference in the author’s direction is significant in terms of the story as well.

1: Japan Otaku Reviews

The gorilla seems to prioritize live energy and momentum, while Shinohara feels like he has calculated everything up to the punchline.

2: Japan Otaku Reviews

>>1

In other words, the cultural festival is a manga.

3: Japan Otaku Reviews

This week’s story about Zico felt like watching the first few pages of Gintama.

4: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx50

It’s so accurate to compare it to a late-night radio show that always curses, it makes me laugh.

13: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx12

>>4

That’s a good example of a balance that makes you understand why such manga becomes popular.

5: Japan Otaku Reviews

It’s like a theory of manga or the know-how of storytelling that is heavily influenced by the master…

6: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx19

The feeling of being a disciple is primarily in the comedic direction, and I don’t really sense the cool characters or the exciting developments that a skilled artist like Shinohara-sensei would typically create.

7: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx9

The logic of gags is straightforward, while the way characters are created is completely different.

62: Japan Otaku Reviews

>>7

There are no big, chubby women.

67: Japan Otaku Reviews

>>62

You were there, weren’t you?

An alien that was about to become linked with the leader of the Shinsengumi.

9: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx13

I didn’t go as far as to say bad things, but I hated the cultural festival, so I prefer Gintama.

10: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx7

Being able to make a joke out of your fake outgoing personality is strong.

11: Japan Otaku Reviews

>>10

Gorilla’s response

12: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx2

This late-night radio-like manga is selling really well…

14: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx2

The manga from the disciple also has a late-night radio vibe…

15: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx1

Isn’t this disciple too much in love with their master?

18: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx20

>>15

I think that anyone who can talk about their hard work preparing for the cultural festival without feeling embarrassed can get along with basically anyone.

16: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx5

Shinohara’s jokes have a sense of being constructed like a skit or a stand-up comedy routine.

17: Japan Otaku Reviews

It’s amazing that you can really make a relatively interesting manzai with that kind of content.

19: Japan Otaku Reviews

I only have memories of preparing for the cultural festival and cleaning…

20: Japan Otaku Reviews

It’s amazing that all three of the works you drew have been turned into anime, disciple.

21: Japan Otaku Reviews

>>20

There’s only one gorilla…

24: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx3

>>21

You only released that one, didn’t you?!

Moreover, how long has the anime been running!! It’s also been adapted into live-action!!

27: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx2

>>24

Shall we do it?

“Dande Lion animated adaptation”

22: Japan Otaku Reviews

It’s a strange relationship where, although the gorilla blooms relatively early and the apprentice has left their corporate job, the apprentice is actually older in terms of age.

23: Japan Otaku Reviews

It’s true that the gorilla is all about talent, but…

When the gorilla started the series, there was a person named Sawai-sensei, who was a bundle of even more amazing talent, so the gorilla thought he had no talent.

25: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx3

>>23

It’s really crazy to go as a gag to where Mr. Sawai and the Kyousuke Usuta from when he was still normal are.

It seems that seeing the two previous examples ends up making him think he should add seriousness, and that has been passed down to his disciples as well.

50: Japan Otaku Reviews

>>25

I thought the comedy style was quite different, but did they see those two as a big wall…?

53: Japan Otaku Reviews

>>50

The original direction might be different, but I think there are definitely some changes being consciously made.

39: Japan Otaku Reviews

>>23

It’s rare to find someone who has read Gintama and shares their thoughts on it.

Even if you remove the parody elements, the work is largely composed of the spirit of gags from the Drifters era, the structure of human-interest stories from around the time of Ken Takakura, and the images of great figures created from past historical works, so it cannot be solely attributed to individual talent.

There is no one else who can imitate, so the ability to absorb, emulate, and take the best parts can be called genius.

An author who thinks they can create an interesting manga solely relying on their own talent cannot make Gintama.

28: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx6

Normally, it’s like a late-night radio program full of bad-mouthing, but why is this gorilla also quite good at heartwarming stories?

29: Japan Otaku Reviews

I think it would be quite interesting if I could do a late-night radio show.

38: Japan Otaku Reviews

>>29

It seems like having a gorilla as the late-night radio host and Shinohara as the scriptwriter would make it incredibly entertaining.

30: Japan Otaku Reviews

It’s amazing how I am connected by such a bond, being a disciple of a gorilla and having Mr. Yabuki as a relative.

31: Japan Otaku Reviews

Since the gorilla debuted without a master, the disciples might be surprisingly cute.

35: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx1

>>31

When the gorilla had his disciple from the Ashi era draw the trash can for the odd jobs, he didn’t say anything, but when he brought in a large number of drawn vinegar kelp boxes, it seems he thought, “Ah, this guy is going to excel.”

32: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx2

It feels a bit off when the disciple turns clichés or meta elements into gag material.

51: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx2

>>32

It tends to give a serious impression.

33: Japan Otaku Reviews

The gorilla drawn by the gorilla is really expressionless, while the gorilla drawn by Teacher Shinohara is full of expression…

34: Japan Otaku Reviews

If they’re going to bring the title back, this gorilla will also appear in the anime… this will be the second time this gorilla becomes an anime…

36: Japan Otaku Reviews

Inserting serious episodes in between is the difference.

37: Japan Otaku Reviews

Should I have a gorilla do the gorilla voice…?

40: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx6

To be honest, I don’t like my master’s serious moments or battles.

76: Japan Otaku Reviews

>>40

It seemed like the disciple was saying that the survey results are declining…

41: Japan Otaku Reviews

The girl is definitely cuter than the disciple.

The guys are favored by the master.

42: Japan Otaku Reviews

I mean, Gintama also created gags quite logically, didn’t it?

43: Japan Otaku Reviews

I think this person and Mr. Matsui have skillfully incorporated their master’s direct style of jokes into their own techniques.

44: Japan Otaku Reviews

What have you been doing since Gintama ended?

45: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx6

>>44

It turned into a cheese steamed bun.

46: Japan Otaku Reviews

>>44

I’m watching AV on the tablet I bought for digital transition.

90: Japan Otaku Reviews

>>46

That episode was somehow good and made me laugh.

47: Japan Otaku Reviews

The gorilla’s part feels like a story from a rakugo performance, while the disciple’s part often feels like a comedy skit.

49: Japan Otaku Reviews

But the part about it shining not in golden brilliance like Gintama, but in a dull silver glow, was really thrilling.

52: Japan Otaku Reviews

The episodes with the marbles and jeans show the influence of the master…

54: Japan Otaku Reviews

I feel that the disciple has strong elements of gags and puzzles.

72: Japan Otaku Reviews

>>54

The puzzle elements were in full swing and the short-term summary of Astra was amazing…

55: Japan Otaku Reviews

When a serious personality mixes with the blood of a twisted gorilla, it becomes a “sukedan.”

56: Japan Otaku Reviews

The gorilla has probably made enough money that it doesn’t need to draw manga anymore…

I trust that if I draw manga again now, I will come up with something interesting.

57: Japan Otaku Reviews

It feels like they are doing logically constructed gags when I look at the Q&A section of the manga.

58: Japan Otaku Reviews

I wasn’t good at cultural festivals, so I’ll try reading Gintama.

59: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx1

It’s funny like a late-night radio show when it gets sarcastic.

As soon as the radio drama starts in the program, it suddenly becomes boring.

However, that radio drama seems to receive more survey responses than the talk show.

60: Japan Otaku Reviews

When I asked if this was okay for the supervision related to Gintama, I got the response of “No, this is actually…” so they seem to be reasonably energetic.

61: Japan Otaku Reviews

It’s been a while since Gintama ended, and the recovery period should be enough by now.

Hurry up with the new release, Gorilla.

63: Japan Otaku Reviews

It’s a pretty straightforward jab, but it’s nice that you can forgive me; we must be good friends.

84: Japan Otaku Reviews

>>63

If I don’t forgive my master’s style, which often includes straightforward ribbing, I would end up being a person with a very small-mindedness.

64: Japan Otaku Reviews

It seems that the manga artist started around 30 and debuted about two years later, which is impressive, isn’t it?

65: Japan Otaku Reviews

I heard that the people here without names are mostly on the gorilla side.

74: Japan Otaku Reviews

>>65

They have eyes that are the color of tobacco tar.

66: Japan Otaku Reviews

There’s only the old man from One Piece left.

Do something about the gorilla.

68: Japan Otaku Reviews

However, the style of storytelling with characters like Moi-chan and Kan-chan is not something we see much in Gintama, so the gags have a quite unique flavor to them.

69: Japan Otaku Reviews

I think the attention to Bossun’s intonation reflects his personality.

70: Japan Otaku Reviews

This kind of thing becomes a joke when someone subordinate does it to someone superior.

On that side, they are half-retired and have reversed their positions, so isn’t this just plain sarcasm?

71: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx4

>>70

No…?

73: Japan Otaku Reviews

>>70

Gintama was made into a live-action movie by Shun Oguri, so it’s still on a higher level even now.

75: Japan Otaku Reviews

I wish I could be as amusingly sarcastic as a gorilla.

77: Japan Otaku Reviews

It’s a gag manga, so it’s fine to make fun of the master, right?

It also accurately describes the differences in direction while seeming to depict it negatively.

78: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx4

If they were to do it, they would probably ask for permission from the gorilla in this way beforehand, this is the type of author they are.

82: Japan Otaku Reviews

>>78

Learn from the master who, without permission, makes others shave their heads and apologize when they get scolded.

79: Japan Otaku Reviews

Look into my eyes.

It’s not the color of tar, it’s jaundice.

80: Japan Otaku Reviews

Kumeda often teases the author of Hayate the Combat Butler, but which one is in a higher position?

81: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx3

>>80

Kumeta is a seasoned veteran.

83: Japan Otaku Reviews

Recently, I saw some impressions of an anime, and it had a double meaning where “meccha light” means “super light” and also included “charai” inside it.

85: Japan Otaku Reviews

But once it has become a cheese steamed bun, it’s already… you know?

86: Japan Otaku Reviews

Even the Taipak people are disciples of the gorilla.

87: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx2

I don’t doubt the gorilla’s talent, but I don’t really think the next work will be a type that will be well-received either.

Well, if you’re tired, I hope you take a good rest…

88: Japan Otaku Reviews

Can a gorilla create something that surpasses the manga it drew?

But if I’ve already earned enough that I don’t need to do that anymore, then I guess it’s fine not to do it.

89: Japan Otaku Reviews

I think the one with the most influence is undoubtedly the gorilla.

91: Japan Otaku Reviews

Gorillas become so established in their style that they reach a point of decline, so it doesn’t happen very often.

  • Related Posts

    [Hunter × Hunter] I really like when they do something like this in fan art that feels like a cool concept.

    Japan Otaku Reviews discusses gameplay changes, currency strategies, and controversial game items, questioning their implications.

    Read more

    [Super Doctor K] Kazuya and Miyasaka-san… finally…

    The speaker expresses fear of losing love to someone better but desires to live forever with Shiori Miyasaka despite height differences.

    Read more

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    You Missed

    [Hunter × Hunter] I really like when they do something like this in fan art that feels like a cool concept.

    • April 14, 2025
    [Hunter × Hunter] I really like when they do something like this in fan art that feels like a cool concept.

    [Super Doctor K] Kazuya and Miyasaka-san… finally…

    • April 14, 2025
    [Super Doctor K] Kazuya and Miyasaka-san… finally…

    [Granblue Fantasy] I can’t catch up to the border…

    • April 14, 2025
    [Granblue Fantasy] I can’t catch up to the border…

    [Pokémon] When I booted it up after a long time, I found that something called a software encyclopedia had been added, and I was trying really hard to fill it in just by trading, but isn’t this quite a struggle?

    • April 14, 2025
    [Pokémon] When I booted it up after a long time, I found that something called a software encyclopedia had been added, and I was trying really hard to fill it in just by trading, but isn’t this quite a struggle?

    [Mega Man X] What do you think about the armor design of the X8?

    • April 14, 2025
    [Mega Man X] What do you think about the armor design of the X8?

    [Vampire Survivors] Since the Sagaemeko collaboration ended fairly quickly, here’s the face I make when playing Seamoon Adventure.

    • April 14, 2025
    [Vampire Survivors] Since the Sagaemeko collaboration ended fairly quickly, here’s the face I make when playing Seamoon Adventure.