When reading manga, the work has HP. First, the initial HP is determined by elements like art style and theme. If it’s difficult to read or understand, the HP decreases rapidly. And… once the HP of a work drops to 0, people completely lose interest in it.
I understand a little.
You read it with a point deduction method, right?
>>2
I thought that if it’s a manga, you enjoy the subsequent developments and story, so isn’t it more of a points-based system?
I think a way of thinking like in that thread picture is interesting too.
>>2
I think that’s proof that the reader has grown up.
When we were kids, everyone loved reading manga.
Even if the initial HP is low, there are times when it can recover…
New character with big breasts +20
Easy cute girl character +50
It’s rare, but there are times when you read something again after a while and find something new.
>>6
When I was browsing through erotic manga, I initially overlooked it, but after reading it closely, I sometimes reevaluate and think, “This expression in this panel is really erotic…”
Loli big breasts +100
Isn’t the variation in initial HP settings too large?
>>8
But that initial homepage needs to make you think, “So this is how you read this manga,” so it’s quite difficult.
It seems that if there are characters or developments that make you think “actually,” it adds to the experience, but if it goes to zero, even that might become uninteresting.
Because this HP won’t recover, I can’t even read manga, even if it’s free.
There are both deductions and additions.
No, I don’t mean to bring out lewd female characters, okay?
There are quite a few instances where a manga I’ve dropped after the first chapter becomes a topic of conversation, leading me to re-read it and get hooked, so I can’t really say anything definitive.
Kagurabachi and so on.
I understand that once HP reaches 0, you lose interest, but it’s not like you can’t recover from that.
I can understand that it’s reasonable to think it’s okay to take a break since it’s considered slip damage.
My initial HP is quite low for magazine-style works.
It will inevitably become a point deduction system.
I’ve experienced getting -100 from an author’s tweet.
There are indeed developments reminiscent of Behoimi.
An example of a manga that makes you say “I get it” usually starts with a promising first chapter, but then it becomes less interesting than expected and goes downhill.
Repeatedly uses ideas from other comics -50
There are indeed cases where something that started from 10 points quickly accumulates additional points.
Even when I’m reading something interesting, there are times when I suddenly think, “If that’s what you’re going to do, then I’m done with this…” and it hits me like a ton of bricks.
Raptor took away all of the HP in one hit.
I don’t remember any work that had such offensive power.
>>26
The destructive power of the bomb was incredible.
>>28
I’ve never seen someone leave points for a bomb before.
>>28
With my dad dead, I’m at zero, and the prostitute bomb gives me a slight recovery, right?
>>61
If it had all gone in a risqué direction, there was a possibility it could have recovered as that kind of work…
It didn’t turn out that way, but…
If the development doesn’t match at all, it will go beyond HP 0 and reach minus.
After losing interest and cutting ties
It is possible to recover and restart from HP with others’ criticism.
It was a work that continued in a nearly dying state from halfway through.
I thought “Watamote” was over, but later I read it again after hearing others’ reviews.
>>31
Why is it that your true capabilities show after the media mix period is over…?
The glasses character awakens and takes off their glasses +150
I really won’t read it if it’s like “Hiroyuki in another world” or a point deduction system.
>>33
“Just with ‘other world’ and ‘Hiroyuki,’ my initial HP will drop to 0.”
I had HP up until halfway, but I hate the ones that suddenly drop it significantly towards the end.
It’s rare for one to stop reading due to a clear reason.
One day, suddenly, it just stops mattering and disappears from your mind, doesn’t it?
My Hero Academia and Blue Lock started from zero with others’ reactions and screenshots online, but once I actually read them, I became so hooked that it boosted my enjoyment by +100.
Since it feels like a serialization meeting, erotic characters would correspond to the initial HP.
Only with the pages of the manga that becomes the thread picture when the thread is started.
I tend to determine initial HP easily.
>>39
First of all, if you don’t have the opportunity to see it, you can’t even build the initial homepage…
Isn’t a serialization a different story?
Since I’m usually catching up or reading summaries, if I had experienced it in real-time, I would have gotten discouraged… that’s also common.
Hmm, how should I put this…
I think momentum is important.
I’ve been reading things like Nausicaä of the Valley of the Wind and the Legend of the Satsuma Rebels recently.
Even during the manga name showdown, we talked about topics like “tips to keep people reading.”
The fact that this manga itself is relentlessly diminishing the HP earned by Fudou-kun’s art with scenes that solely discuss the methodology in text is something that can’t be put into words.
I think it’s impressive that the Otherworldly Fiery Sea King managed to survive after all those debuffs.
>>46
The synergy of “Rekkaioh” in the “Isekai” is seriously intriguing, and after the restraints are lifted, it’s undeniably super interesting…
>>46
I actually fell to a really bad place.
Towards the end of volume 1, I cut off my relationship with the editor.
I was able to recover.
The expression “HP” might indeed be accurate because it’s only after going through it completely that it can be evaluated on a point-addition basis.
The title or the name of the webcomic and the first panel can sometimes decide whether or not I choose to read it.
It’s not that there are no opportunities like that in HP, nor is it an instant death… Is it that there are no encounters?
Ryūtsu is repeatedly on the brink of death and making a great recovery.
In other words, it can be considered that Mr. Monkey likes SM.
A manga that stays at a level like Hyunkel’s.
There is.
>>50
It’s more like the manga is stagnant.
If the readers have come this far, they might be caught in a lingering attachment that they can’t sever now…
This is not a series meeting, but the selection meeting for a manga award.
With subscription services that offer unlimited reading, you can really understand the quality of the artwork and the importance of the cover.
It’s common to have works that become HP0 just from the title…
>>56
Personally, everything with those ridiculously long titles lately is just like that.
>>60
That’s already a magical realm where there are so many similar works that you can’t grasp the content from the title, so they won’t even be read… yeah.
>>63
I understand various circumstances, but including that, the only expressions that seem to come out are about del.
It seems that there is significance in continuing a super long series…
Even if it becomes boring, as long as I’m reading, my HP isn’t 0.
If you stop reading, HP 0.
If there’s fluff or gacha in the title, the HP will drop to single digits all at once.
I want the one-shot to be concluded as a one-shot.
I want my HP back from an ending that feels like it’s aiming for serialization.
The HP theory came in really smoothly.
You’re good at articulating things.
Compared to that, I…
It feels like works that are overly meticulous in the beginning are almost never read.
>>65
It tends to feel like just an explanation without any exciting points…
The flashback scenes continue for several episodes, and it’s already overwhelming.
I was buying it as a standalone book instead of a serialized version, and I missed somewhere along the way.
Ah, I wonder where the difference lies between thinking I have to buy the previous volume too and then deciding that maybe I don’t need to buy it after all…
The HP clogs from the Sam 8 editorial department were amazing.
Dr.STONE gives the impression of having infinite HP at the start.
This is how to read manga from Jump.
The topic being talked about here is +50.
>>73
It’s frustrating to be influenced by a bulletin board, but this is relatively common.
It’s not just here, but the topic that’s been discussed is that it will increase the initial HP, right?
On the contrary, if it’s not as bad as I thought, the HP decreases quickly.
Sam8 was printing stuff like that without printing Demon Slayer, so I can only think that all the editors were hallucinating.
Professor Matsui said something similar about the theory of defense power.
While being interesting is important, it’s also crucial to have a level of defense that prevents readers from feeling tired or uncomfortable while reading.
Personally, I don’t have many memories of experiencing recovery.
Do you have any specific examples, Anonymous?
>>77
If it were Jump Plus, I was able to recover and watch it until the end after the childhood friend who is the heroine from BEAT & MOTION appeared.
Once it’s released as a series, I think it will get busy with fluctuations in numbers, decreasing and recovering.
The theory that Matsui Yuusei explained in the manga course resonates more with me.
It’s the same in that it won’t be read at gauge 0.
The gauge recovers with the excitement of the opening and climax.
The scene that is not interesting but necessary as a connection during that time is hard to understand, and the gauge decreases.
This website should not forget that time will pass and things will decrease even if nothing special is being done.
In biweekly or monthly serializations, it’s common for readers to not even be aware that their HP is gradually decreasing.
In the early stages of D4C on Jump Plus, I wasn’t worried about the HP decreasing separately and was just reading, but then it suddenly started to recover.
Maybe it’s the old woman’s fault.
The maximum HP changes depending on how the previous work ended.
I didn’t read Act-Age because I didn’t like the prickly atmosphere in the beginning.
I started reading it because it became a topic of conversation at the bar, so “Gero” is recovery magic.
Well, I caught a Zaraki in a good spot, but…
>>86
In the early stages, both the drawings and the content were tough.
In the mundane slice-of-life genre, the HP decreases by 1 for each episode.
In the end, it will be like “Well, the next story will probably just continue with the same mundane daily life,” and my HP will reach 0.
>>88
It’s a rom-com where a couple’s formation is guaranteed from the start, and it has turned out like this.
Toxic parents
Bullying in schools
Diversity
Raptor’s HP zero means the old man is dead, after all.
I was enjoying reading it, but suddenly I’m out of HP.
>>91
It feels like my father’s death was due to self-damage, leaving just 1 HP, and that didn’t carry over to the next round, resulting in an automatic KO.
When innovative approaches and developments emerge
Max HP increases significantly.
At the moment Raptar died, I was able to maintain it with “What should I do from here?”, but I couldn’t cook it well.
I was a little disappointed because I liked the way the doctor looked.
>>93
I understand.
I was curious about it, so when I went to check occasionally, the shota was talking about incomprehensible things and ended up taking their own life.
The first HP I had decreased rapidly, but…
There are also works with a strange gauge added separately that continue to be read enthusiastically.
There’s something a lot in Magapoke.
Raptor could withstand until death at that HP, but it turned out like a guerrilla organization and went down to zero…
The rapta’s father’s death was fatal damage, but if it was handled well in the next story, it would have returned to normal.
The house turned into a garbage dump at lightning speed, and the protagonist went crazy, which led to a zero outcome.
I understand.
Kinnikuman was exactly this.
>>101
The author gets into a scandal on social media -50
In a world overflowing with entertainment like this,
Reading manga takes quite a bit of time and is tiring in itself.
Well, if it doesn’t resonate with me, I can’t continue reading.
The sequel to that hot topic! The previous work is ruined at the beginning! And HP drops to 0.
If I keep reading out of inertia, there are times when I think it’s not so bad lately, right?
It is difficult for someone who cut ties without even maintaining inertia to return.
When I started reading, I thought it was going to be a typical template development, but if I was pleasantly surprised in a good way, my evaluation of it goes up.
When an erotic manga artist draws a general audience manga, they do not include erotic content -99
>>106
However, you see… that would defeat the purpose of going public in the first place.
Even in ecchi manga, it feels kind of dull.
>>106
Rather, I depicted a healthy everyday life and my HP increased, and later, when I drew an erotic comic version with the same composition, my HP became ten times greater, so I can’t say it is definitively – .
I think it’s simply about whether or not you are concerned with the factors that lead to point deductions in a points deduction system or point addition system.
It won’t recover unless there is something extraordinary.
If updates are irregular, the HP will gradually decrease.
There are small deductions that accumulate, like when the panel layout is difficult to read.
Every time I take slip damage, I can cut even if my health isn’t at 0.
The author stands out negatively -95
The thread is starting to feel like a Sachi recording.
>>118
The series has ended – 5 trillion.
If the paneling is hard to see, it really takes a huge toll on your HP…
>>117
So that’s the expression you came up with! It’s normally interesting… I have expectations since it’s supposed to be erotic, but if there’s no erotic content, honestly, it just becomes a letdown…!
A writer whose name is good and easy to read is
It’s definitely beneficial to recover health on every page, isn’t it?
Move to another medium -50
By the way, the story rewinds -999.
If you suddenly go in a direction that you don’t like or are not interested in, it can lead to immediate demise.
The picture is messy and I can’t tell what it’s doing, which makes me feel a decrease in HP.
The general issue with erotic manga artists is that they tend to be simply uninteresting and not erotic either…
And even if you add some ero, it still doesn’t go that far with general ero…
I suddenly went down to HP 0 in the manga about a ninja who can read minds on Jump+.
>>132
I want to pass down the tragedy of the brainwashing senior as a lesson.
>>139
What’s crazy is that after doing all that, it seems the author never intended to make that character a villain, which is the most insane part.
Why are you nonchalantly acting like an ally?
>>132
It’s quite severe that it has come to be perceived that way, even though it’s not primarily about ninjas…
>>140
It’s true, now that I remember, the main character wasn’t a ninja…
Then what about the main character?
>>157
It was a manga with a setting where ordinary people with special abilities are drawn to the heroine.
Rather, it’s a family of ninjas for generations, so a ninja who is doing ninja work stands out.
I subscribe to Morning and read all the manga.
Bad Baby doesn’t cry anymore at all.
Anyway, there were too many lines, making it hard to read, and my HP was continuously draining.
I have seen countless examples of people rambling on and on about how boring something is, so I wonder if that really is the case…
>>137
If it’s a work I like, I can say whatever, but if it’s a subtle work, my reputation drops with a nameless explanation.
Professor Matsui was also talking about a similar concept in terms of defense.
I can read it even though I don’t understand. +15
>>142
In anime and movies, there is movement, so it happens occasionally, but in manga and novels, it’s tough…
It’s fine if it’s a web series.
If it’s in a weekly magazine, it’s like paying for this… because the magazine’s own homepage decreases.
When my favorite manga ends, there’s about a -5 debuff on the entire magazine.
Sincerity is just a facade, isn’t it?
The dragon and strawberry had ridiculously low initial HP.
>>147
Since then, my HP has been increasing, but I was worried it would drop to zero after the match against Yamano-be, yet it’s still continuing to rise now.
The suggestion box for KanColle was popular on the bulletin board.
The author said that the cancellation had been decided quite a while ago due to sales, and it ended with the homepage still remaining…
>>148
No matter how popular it is on the bulletin board, it doesn’t often lead to sales, so it’s unavoidable.
No matter how many of these HPs there are, it doesn’t matter whether I buy the paperback or not.
The title includes “slow life” – 100
I could tolerate being a ninja; that guy isn’t really a bad kid at heart.
Senpai… you are a creature that shouldn’t be alive…
Huh, are they really going to do something like that!? If it’s just the impact of that, it can stay at a decrease in HP, but…
I feel like being brought down to zero from there is usually a pattern where the shocking development isn’t being handled properly.
I think I’m under a status ailment when I’m reading something like Bobobo-bo Bo-bobo.
>>154
Someone who directly interferes with the HP gauge.
>>159
The one in the middle mixed with Bobobo-bo Bo-bobo.
This can happen even outside of manga and anime.
>>156
If anything, it’s also about interpersonal relationships.
It’s fine if Brainwashing Senpai becomes an ally.
Please punish wicked deeds.
>>155
The final volume comment for Asumikakeru had about -50…
That’s why you’re not selling… I used to love reading it every week, so how do you expect me to feel about this…?
>>135
It’s basically dying almost exactly as it is, just a very small part.
If you’re worried about inflation, the damage is huge; but if you read it all at once in a paperback, it’s not that bad.
There are some interesting ones and some that I like, but just being a “Narou” type title makes it go down by about -80.
Works with long titles tend to have low early HP.
>>164
The me that is 〇〇
If you do △△
Because I did XX.
I will do □□.
>>164
The expelled cheat-giving magician enjoys a carefree second life. ~I can not only grant ‘enhancement points’ to weapons but to everything, and I can deactivate the effects at any time with my will, but are the remaining people all right?~
>>182
Shut up!
Manga artists who draw erotic comics that are just the same daily routines without any eroticism make me think, “Oh, what a waste…”
During the doujin days, the story had a bit more ups and downs, so I wonder if it’s the editor’s decision.
Deep Layer Laputa and Sincere Scramble
The author’s sense of ethics is too misaligned with the readers -100
I wonder what it is…
>>166
It’s more about being a popular web comic than having an ethical perspective, so it’s all about who goes viral.
It was more like it flopped rather than went viral…
>>166
It feels like Raputa has a rough flavoring, as if to say, “Kids these days seem to like provocative developments, right?” regarding their sense of ethics.
The serialization will not resume -100
>>167
Freiren has become this.
If you’re going to take a long break twice, then I might as well wait to read it until it’s finished.
It’s a genuine scramble, but since the final episode was properly wrapped up, I trust the author.
However, the way the final episode was portrayed made me realize that the author really wanted to make the senpai the heroine… that’s what I understood.
>>168
I found out about the finale from this post +100
Don’t bring curses on specific works in a thread like this.
I can’t tell if the number of ninjas and yakuza is increasing or decreasing.
>>179
When the flower tiger comes out, it definitely takes a lot of damage.
>>179
It feels like I’m recovering the HP I lost in the executive battle during the Hakkyokudo battle.
It seems that the flower tiger won’t be able to recover, which is troubling.
Aging -5
Aging -5
The author’s main battlefield has become SNS -100
>>188
There are many political tweets and reposts -10000
>>190
Stop it, stop it!
>>190
It’s not that creators shouldn’t have their own thoughts, but if they’re going to do original work, supplementary setting details, or fan service, I would like them to separate their accounts.
The author has died HP-100
I realize that the +5 I accumulated by reading in one go is steadily decreasing while I wait for updates.
It feels like the annoying villain simply exists in this world just to be knocked down by the protagonist.
The protagonist probably intends to earn points by punching that guy, but since he’s causing a ruckus, it tends to end up being more that he has already earned points.
Who is this character again…? -5
Who is this character again… -5
It is common in slow-running serialized manga.
>>195
I can’t tell the characters apart – it’s common to have a -5 as well.
It’s basically my fault.
Stop trying to identify it.
The author has become a shareholder and is supporting Himasora Akane. -100
The development of Laputa seems like the author doesn’t particularly like it either.
The author of Yu-Gi-Oh was starting to become quite malicious in his political criticism with newly drawn images towards the end of his career.
Konami is too annoying.
In reality, the initial HP seems quite low at a glance with the long title and mediocre art.
![[Normal Light Music Club] Episode 60 Review: It was a great live scene…](https://otaku-reviews.net/wp-content/uploads/2025/03/1eb81227.png)
![[Gundam SEED] There were parts that elicited sympathy, but the conclusion is trash!](https://otaku-reviews.net/wp-content/uploads/2025/03/8559ed8e.jpg)
![[Uma Musume] Dobomejiro (real name: Mejiro Dobel) and Toramomejiro (real name: Mejiro Ramone) were arrested on suspicion of distributing obscene drawings.](https://otaku-reviews.net/wp-content/uploads/2025/03/e351c2d5.jpg)