Home » Manga » [R.E.D.] A work that has anticipated diversity too much.

[R.E.D.] A work that has anticipated diversity too much.

  • Manga
  • February 27, 2025
  • 0 Comments

1: Japan Otaku Reviews

I wonder if Americans feel confused after reading this.

17: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx2

>>1

I don’t think people who are really right-wing would acknowledge it.

If that’s not the case, then just enjoy it normally.

2: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx13

What are the readers so worried about?

Huh?

3: Japan Otaku Reviews

>>2

There are only worrying factors!

4: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx5

It is a masterpiece, so it remains in the hearts of those who have read it.

It may no longer be something that should come from the heart…

5: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx2

If ninjas and yakuza can be adapted into anime, then I thought this work could be too… but it’s full of problematic depictions in a different vector.

6: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx3

It seems like there isn’t anything that can’t be done if it’s around Netflix.

13: Japan Otaku Reviews

>>6

There are countries that would be problematic if they were to expand overseas, so it seems even more difficult.

If it’s exclusively distributed in Japan, there might be a chance.

7: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx5

If it were to be adapted into film, I definitely want to see my favorite last line from Terence.

8: Japan Otaku Reviews

Black and yellow are such straightforward names that it’s funny.

10: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx6

>>8

Red won’t work either…

9: Japan Otaku Reviews

I want the scene of the cross-dresser dying to be visualized; it’s really cool.

22: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx5

>>9

Huh, a story about a cross-dresser attacking an elementary school and killing teachers and kids left and right!?

23: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx3

>>22

I can… I can’t!!

11: Japan Otaku Reviews

If anything, Angie’s real name also includes “White,” which is quite direct.

It’s not a derogatory term, but…

12: Japan Otaku Reviews

I forgot her name, but I liked theNative American girl who survived; she was cute.

20: Japan Otaku Reviews

>>12

Scarlet is so cute, right?

But the ending is too resolved…

14: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx6

I know it, but I cry every time at the last scene with the orange and the new red.

15: Japan Otaku Reviews

Yellow?

Is there any sign of Iyūrō?

16: Japan Otaku Reviews

That red over there and this red over here, it’s impossible, impossible!

18: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx3

You’re making a fool of Ieyasu…

19: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx2

It feels like there’s a problem if you say this is not good, so please push forward and make it into an anime.

21: Japan Otaku Reviews

The scene of the first menstruation in the final act is a good scene, but I wonder if this includes some kind of fetish? It clouds my thoughts.

24: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx5

Gray’s battles are always a win.

Everyone is super cool.

79: Japan Otaku Reviews

>>24

Diving while shooting dual pistols, or quickly drawing while gracefully dodging and only getting shot through the coat, the power of the artwork is amazing.

25: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx2

For now, let’s make it into an anime, and if we get yelled at, we’ll just apologize!

27: Japan Otaku Reviews

>>25

I want to commit seppuku!

26: Japan Otaku Reviews

It’s a story from the era of westward expansion, so what elements are there to get angry about?

28: Japan Otaku Reviews

Apologizing doesn’t seem like it’s enough…

29: Japan Otaku Reviews

What, a scene where Indian corpses are piled up and shot at in 4DX!?

35: Japan Otaku Reviews

>>29

It’s still too lacking in recognition to be made into a theatrical film…

30: Japan Otaku Reviews

Let’s keep Captain Blue in our hearts!

31: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx3

>>30

Abnormal person…

32: Japan Otaku Reviews

It’s not like I’m depicting that white people are superior or that black people and Indians are inferior…

It just presents the past wars and massacres from the perspective of the Indigenous people…

33: Japan Otaku Reviews

It’s safe theory because it discriminates equally.

34: Japan Otaku Reviews

How many times are you going to create a thread with the same text?

36: Japan Otaku Reviews

Aside from the others, aren’t the members of Squad A a bit too eccentric for former soldiers?

Especially those who use a lasso to strangle and say guns are vulgar and smelly while using throwing knives.

37: Japan Otaku Reviews

It’s a masterpiece, but since it doesn’t get talked about much, I can forgive it somewhat…

The author has been a Kamen Rider person for a long time now…

38: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx1

>>37

Can I talk about my younger sister, Teacher Nagisa, today!?

70: Japan Otaku Reviews

>>38

Can I talk about the roe deer today!?

72: Japan Otaku Reviews

>>70

Ah…! Feel free to talk about Wolf Gun as much as you like!

39: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx3

A manga that makes the people who see it love Tanegashima.

40: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx2

To be honest, unlike the overwhelming majority in the minority,

Native Americans (Indians) probably won’t be much of a problem since they don’t have much power.

41: Japan Otaku Reviews

I mean, the most outrageous thing is Greenwell’s thing, right?

46: Japan Otaku Reviews

>>41

But that Gray over there is really cool.

Also, it was someone who was disliked in the Blue Squad…

42: Japan Otaku Reviews

If they did it on Netflix, it would definitely be a disaster—Greenwell would go wild.

Was it before that time?

43: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx1

Greenwell stormed into the elementary school and shot both teachers and students indiscriminately, but is portrayed without glorification as a jerk…

44: Japan Otaku Reviews

I read this and thought, “Long barrel sniper muskets are so cool!” but it seems that the actual matchlock guns were used for aiming through castle gunports, so they aren’t particularly related to accuracy.

45: Japan Otaku Reviews

Well, but having Terrence say that the history of this country started when the white people came might be a bit too much…

47: Japan Otaku Reviews

I kind of like Yellow too much.

48: Japan Otaku Reviews

The monster Terensroid fights while replacing one of its arms.

49: Japan Otaku Reviews

I thought that even though it was revenge, since I killed so many people, I wouldn’t be able to die peacefully.

A more intense end than I expected, a sad memory.

50: Japan Otaku Reviews

In the end, they died consumed by hatred, still driven by the obsession that Blue was still alive…

51: Japan Otaku Reviews

Tanegashima is nice, but hate songs are also good, right?

52: Japan Otaku Reviews

The story of Barnie settling things with Goldsmith after chasing him is just too good…

53: Japan Otaku Reviews

If I dare say, there was a feeling that towards the end, there was too much reliance on Murasaki’s eccentric behavior?

54: Japan Otaku Reviews

The chances of Kamen Rider SPIRITS being adapted into an anime are still higher.

55: Japan Otaku Reviews

If an Indian tribe is fundamentally a matriarchal society and a lone male Red survives, the Wishha clan is doomed to extinction.

However, the part about how things change with Scarlett is not explained very well, so it’s a bit difficult to understand.

57: Japan Otaku Reviews

>>55

If Red and Scarlet meet and end up making babies, it would seriously be a big deal, right?

56: Japan Otaku Reviews

What is it?

Are you saying it’s discriminatory to depict a revenge tale with Native Americans as the main characters?

58: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx1

I really like it except for the preachy parts.

65: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx4

>>58

The theme inevitably sounds preachy.

68: Japan Otaku Reviews

>>65

I’m sorry, to be specific, I really like everything except the orphanage part.

Purple swordsmanship is good, isn’t it…?

To twist the sword that was stabbed into the throat and deliver the final blow…

106: Japan Otaku Reviews

>>58

I understand what you want to say, but thematically, it’s just not possible…

59: Japan Otaku Reviews

The gun action is cool.

It’s quite rare in manga.

60: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx1

I like Gray’s old percussion revolver.

61: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx1

I hope they make an anime adaptation, whether it’s on Amazon Prime or Netflix.

66: Japan Otaku Reviews

>>61

I want you to do it… very carefully from start to finish.

62: Japan Otaku Reviews

America has a ton of self-deprecating movies, so they are definitely more tolerant than Japan.

63: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx1

There’s no way such a strange mechanism for a revolver exists!

It exists…

64: Japan Otaku Reviews

The door illustration hiding naked Scarlet’s groin with a hate song is incredibly erotic.

67: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx2

I think it’s a bit excessive for two unrelated Japanese people to be racking up kill scores for both sides.

From both sides, it must feel like, “What are these guys who fight for their lives out of a little sense of obligation…?!”

69: Japan Otaku Reviews

Wasn’t it around the time of Karakuri Circus?

I feel like Kenichi Muraeda was involved in the dialect collaboration for the Nagasaki edition.

71: Japan Otaku Reviews

I like the scene where a gun is pressed against Gray’s temple and jaw to threaten him.

73: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx4

I’m struck by the image of a person who makes their own bullets and ends up with a shortage, and when they use someone else’s, it misfires, leading them to shout, “That’s why you can’t trust other people’s bullets!” before dying.

75: Japan Otaku Reviews

>>73

At the very beginning, actually, I lost the huge axe I had there.

81: Japan Otaku Reviews

>>73

The scene where they were saying something like “The yellow clip-fed rifle is seriously amazing” was also impressive.

74: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx2

Can I talk about the BIBLE!?

It’s practically RED!!

76: Japan Otaku Reviews

Isn’t that axe stronger than a hate song in terms of power?

77: Japan Otaku Reviews

The cavalry’s cross-dresser isn’t related to Red age-wise, right? They died in a place that doesn’t seem related…

78: Japan Otaku Reviews

I really like this scene.

Please… person… it’s you who has lived through that sin. Please… person… but… Red!! Don’t cry anymore!! Hey!! Hey!! I’m here too, so… you’re not alone!! Don’t cry!!… Hey… Is it sad? Hey, is it terrible? Did you encounter it alone…? It’s so terrible and painful, but I’m also a wish!!!

I really like this scene.

80: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx2

I love the poem of the bird that cannot sing, which was first revealed in the hate song.

87: Japan Otaku Reviews

>>80

Red’s little hands are broken and it’s very visually painful.

82: Japan Otaku Reviews

Angie getting worked up against Scarlet in the final match is so cute.

83: Japan Otaku Reviews

Red is

84: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx1

>>83

The colors of Kabuki actors.

85: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx2

I absolutely believe that Gray’s voice actor is Hiroshi Yamadera.

86: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx2

It’s strange that Yellow is still strong even when approached…

90: Japan Otaku Reviews

>>86

Even when blind, I’m strong…

88: Japan Otaku Reviews

After quitting the military, getting married, and running a restaurant, the past came chasing after me.

92: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx1

>>88

If you were laughing while tearing apart women and children, then there’s nothing that can be done…

89: Japan Otaku Reviews

It seems that Nanashi likes Baker-san.

91: Japan Otaku Reviews

It’s strange that the skill trees for close range and long distance are maxed out.

93: Japan Otaku Reviews

It’s amazing that the electronic version of this has been released.

94: Japan Otaku Reviews

Even though Yellow has almost lost their eyesight, how come they still manage to throw accurately?

95: Japan Otaku Reviews

Do you want to hear about the Yellow Southwestern War?

99: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx3

>>95

You’re here, right?

For now, digging into the backbone of homosexuality.

96: Japan Otaku Reviews

It was a journey where I kept losing more and more, but still, Yellow is strong.

97: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx1

It’s amazing that I’ve managed to write this much while moving from one serialized magazine to another.

It got a bit sluggish in the latter half, but it was well folded up.

98: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx2

It’s really interesting, but there are too many sensitivities.

100: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx3

Murazaki’s situation is too intertwined with religious views and immaturity to be summed up simply as being gay.

101: Japan Otaku Reviews

I can’t help but fall in love with the yellow character who stands out so much.

I’m also liked by psycho homos…

108: Japan Otaku Reviews

>>101

I feel like there are many delicious depictions throughout the story, especially with scenes where the protagonist’s partner faces the past and overcomes it until the end.

I feel like RED is slowing down in the second half, but the final finishing scene is great, isn’t it?

102: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx1

I can see it!! I can see it!!

Angie… no, Lady Annie!!

It’s red… it’s the red sun!!

103: Japan Otaku Reviews

This is about all I know regarding the creation of stories where Indians take revenge on white people.

104: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx2

I think it’s amazing that they killed off the entire Blue Squad after giving them character.

I thought that about half of them would definitely die as indistinguishable mob characters when the first list was released.

105: Japan Otaku Reviews

It’s good that it’s not a simple opposition between white people and people of color.

109: Japan Otaku Reviews

>>105

It would be best for Red to die after achieving revenge…!

113: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx4

>>109

Die already~

117: Japan Otaku Reviews

>>113

That gaze… the scene of Goldsmith’s death.

107: Japan Otaku Reviews

If an entire clan is wiped out regardless of race, it’s no surprise if you lose your mind.

110: Japan Otaku Reviews

The one-eyed middle manager was quite interesting.

Is it Terence?

111: Japan Otaku Reviews

Murasaki was thoroughly destroyed too.

112: Japan Otaku Reviews

In the end, will RED and Scarlet have offspring?

115: Japan Otaku Reviews

>>112

I died.

116: Japan Otaku Reviews

>>112

I’m dead…

114: Japan Otaku Reviews

I like this manga, but I thought it was minor, so I’m surprised it has grown so much.

118: Japan Otaku Reviews

Regardless of what Netflix is or isn’t, it’s something interesting as a manga.

The parody by Shiina from some time ago made me laugh.

119: Japan Otaku Reviews

Well, Goldsmith is saved by his separation from Barni…

  • Related Posts

    [Oishinbo] Hamburgers for breakfast?

    Hamburg steak, often eaten for breakfast in Germany, is debated in Japan, with mixed reviews on its morning appeal.

    Read more

    [Unknown] I started reading yesterday and have read up to volume 5.

    Japan Otaku Reviews praises “I Love You So Much: 100 Girlfriends,” highlighting its humor and intense storytelling.

    Read more

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    You Missed

    [Oishinbo] Hamburgers for breakfast?

    • February 27, 2025
    [Oishinbo] Hamburgers for breakfast?

    [BanG Dream!] “Why do you have to make Shoko do this!? Come on, walk properly!”

    • February 27, 2025
    [BanG Dream!] “Why do you have to make Shoko do this!? Come on, walk properly!”

    [Uma Musume: Pretty Derby] I was looking into the two kids and found that the big star on their forehead is really cute!

    • February 27, 2025
    [Uma Musume: Pretty Derby] I was looking into the two kids and found that the big star on their forehead is really cute!

    [Unknown] I started reading yesterday and have read up to volume 5.

    • February 27, 2025
    [Unknown] I started reading yesterday and have read up to volume 5.

    [Super Mario] I want to hear you talk about Chibi-deka Island once in a while.

    • February 27, 2025
    [Super Mario] I want to hear you talk about Chibi-deka Island once in a while.

    [Heisei Haizanhei Sumire-chan] The great evil falls──..

    • February 27, 2025
    [Heisei Haizanhei Sumire-chan] The great evil falls──..