Originally, it has a vibe of “I’m actually amazing, but I’m just an ordinary guy, haha,” but even so, you can see that the manga version is making an effort to soften that intensity.

The anime version seems to deliberately emphasize a somewhat outdated “yare yare” type protagonist, and I think it’s quite questionable, don’t you think!?

I don’t know about the manga, but the anime is pretty interesting.

I can definitely understand that opinions might be divided compared to the quality of the manga version.

I think the action is doing better than I expected.

If you look up, there’s no limit around here.

I like it, but if you think that way, then I guess that’s how it is.

The comic version has reduced the elements of being heartbroken and the cynical vibe, making it feel just right.

Will the tone of the conversation continue like this in the future?

I’m worried that when the anime ends, it will feel like the original story is over too.

It’s my fault for expecting it on my own, but I was disappointed because it wasn’t as strong as I hoped.

The content does not match the broadcasting slot and Nishikawa’s opening.

I wish it had been on the U channel slot about two hours later.

The manga was an SSR of persuasive swordsmanship, so why…

>>21

The manga depicts cutting through a straw mat with a dull blade.

The match with Henblitz is resolved instantly with “Start!”, making the difference in strength immediately clear.

In the anime, I didn’t feel much strength because of the ongoing swordplay.

Thanks to the comic adaptation, it became popular, but the original work gets carried away.

Isn’t the pace of the story’s development a bit fast in episode 3?

I’m worried that it won’t end in a neat way within one season.

It’s not bad, but… I’m not sure…

Are we really going to go down the route of the original work being several times darker than the comic adaptation? I’m just feeling anxious about it already.

>>26

The original work is quite similar in that regard.

The manga has toned it down quite a bit.

It can’t be helped. Originally, Square Enix wasn’t very enthusiastic about manga, but when Akita Shoten brought in SSR and it sold well, the anime became Square Enix’s lead, so it inevitably had to be based on the original work.

Are you launching a full-scale attack on the Narou genre?

>>29

I don’t know if it’s in the original work, but I definitely want the scene with the tentacles when shaking hands with the blacksmith to be included.

Manga makes action easy to see.

The original author…

Why is the leader dressed like a sex-crazed woman?

In this day and age, if you change anything from the original, it is immediately labeled as a “rape” of the original work, so the current rule in anime production is to not alter anything at all.

If you like manga, why not just enjoy manga?

>>40

It was precisely because the manga was interesting that I wanted to see it come to life.

There was a foolish troll, but you can measure whether it’s decent based on whether or not to manage this.

Basically, I want the isekai genre to lean more towards manga adaptations…

In the original work, when seeing the disciple after a long time, they are completely flustered and ask, “Who are you?!”

In the comic adaptation, it can’t be that you mistake your grown-up disciple for someone else.

I can see that you have come to change your impression quite a bit.

I thought there wouldn’t be those kinds of actions…

>>45

The vice captain is wagging his tail too much… I thought.

>>45

It’s all thanks to the power of the manga adaptation creators.

>>46

If you were reading the anime adapting the original work, then it’s already a defeat.

>>53

It’s only natural that it’s an adaptation of the original work, not the manga’s anime adaptation, rather than something like a spin-off.

There is quite a twist in the original work and the comic adaptation.

Moreover, the best-selling version is the comic edition from a different publisher.

The situation is already messed up.

At first glance, I was relieved that it was just as boring as it seemed.

How many times did Henburittsu-kun die? It’s a bit disappointing that it got cut.

The vice captain is acting like just a fool!

If the original fans are happy, then I guess it’s good.

Basically, it’s just that the protagonist has become an old man, so it can be even tougher for those who don’t match.

After watching the first episode, I realized that I wanted to see the manga version animated, so I haven’t watched it since.

When anime is based on a novel, we can’t expect much from the Spurl battle…

I have the impression that comic discussions are often held here too.

It seems that Spur is just a weakling in the original work.

>>65

I heard that I’m just a nameless but incredibly strong mob character.

>>65

It seems that the past done in the manga isn’t in the original source.

>>74

Seriously? I’m disappointed. The original author should read the original work.

Most of it is popular comics, right?

The drugstore has an anime that includes elements of a tax evasion version of a comic adaptation.

I saw that it’s said to be almost the same as “Kenka Shoubai,” is that true?

Visually, it becomes even creepier because an old man is surrounded by young girls.

It’s only interesting when following the original work if the original is genuinely good, so sometimes a bit of alteration is necessary.

Well, I’m fully aware that it’s rude, but the manga version is enough.

To be honest, if you’re being serious, you’re expecting too much…

The manga is good.

I’m worried that if it’s faithful to the original version, the protagonist will come off as creepy and I’ll just get criticized, lol.

I think everyone didn’t have any expectations.

>>77

At the point of turning it into an anime, I was thinking it should be the manga instead…

But the rights belong to the original creator…

The manga version is going to keep selling more and more.

Was there no young people’s party and love talk in the original work?

In the manga, the lewd outfits have been nerfed, right?

>>83

It’s not included.

It’s just that it’s less noticeable because it’s black and white.

The anime is not even strictly based on the original work, which is terrible.

I only watch anime, but I don’t think it’s that creepy.

Isn’t the captain’s sexual desire coming towards you more unpleasant?

>>86

While others are showing feelings of parent-child or teacher-student bonds, the captain alone has romantic feelings…

>>86

The leader has no time left! The old man has no choice but to take responsibility and take over as the leader!

Original work B

Manga S

Anime D

Well, even if you lose that “thank goodness” feeling in a Narou work, the viewers won’t be happy about it, right?

Aren’t there a lot of people who only watch anime?

I’m impressed you thought to start with anime.

I thought the manga was tough to handle, but the artwork was incredible, so I was able to read it.

The one-on-one duel scene featured a level of action that is quite rare to see.

The content of the original work is pretty much crap.

This is the first time I’ve started from the manga, read the original work, and found it so painful that I gave up.

I thought it would be nice to be surrounded by my former disciples’ cute kids, but it’s been 20 years since they flew the nest!?

By the way, this evaluation is not just from anonymous sources.

The original work and its comic adaptation have sold a total of 8 million copies, but out of that, 7 million copies are the comic adaptation.

>>94

Naso

Nin

>>103

Unlike the old light novels, there are some where the comic adaptation seems to be the main focus…

>>103

Since the original has sold over a million copies, it can’t be that bad, right…?

>>94

7 million copies is amazing!

However, the flair of manga is still well done, so I can understand it.

The original story is not being told here either…

I’ve seen quite a few people say that even if the original work is difficult, they can still read the comic.

The novel version is still being indecisive even after shaking off the illusion of my father…

It’s a typical “chi-gyu” move where he seems to consider the feelings of women around him, but he’s not considerate at all.

Rather, the manga version is surely full of the teacher’s storytelling.

The fact that only the manga is a topic of discussion suggests that the original work is, well…

>>98

It seems to be the greatest humiliation for the original authors on Narou.

The fact that the comic adaptation is more popular is…

>>107

I think the comic adaptation is the most interesting.

The original author should read manga.

>>99

I wonder if they think this is interesting.

It takes time for a disciple who has only been taught the basics to achieve great success.

>>100

I’m not sure about the rest, but it sounds like they learned swordsmanship while being taken care of in their childhood, so perhaps they rose to prominence due to their talent on their own.

If you were to say about this work, it would rather be more like, “Just be more confident… why so self-deprecating?” Isn’t that the type?

It seems like something terrible will happen once the ID is out.

I suppose my job is to take a screenshot of that…

The original author should bow to the manga adaptation author and delegate all authority, even from now.

The superficial humility covers a mentality like that of a protagonist from a light novel, making it even worse.

It’s better to blame it on youthful indiscretion than to compare it to other Narou (self-published web novels).

Making the protagonist an old man had the opposite effect.

I heard it’s because the publisher is different for the original work and the manga.

The person in the thread also said, “If we had wanted to meet, we could have easily done so given how close we are! For 20 years…! I’m so sorryyy!!” while drinking alcohol and talking to the teacher in the story…

About work…

Whenever “Cheese Grant” is animated, whether it leans more towards the original work or the manga.

I think it has become a work that is brought up for reference.

>>113

The manga is already original, you know.

It was popular because it had changes in the comic adaptation, so isn’t it going to be tough to stick to the original?

I don’t know if the other sister disciples have also been around for 20 years, but maybe they were incredibly quick to learn; even so, they will be around 30.

>>116

The thread image has met the teacher the fastest.

At that time, the teacher still had a youthful face.

By the time the other two were there, the teacher had already become an old man.

I read the manga because it had good reviews, but honestly, the manga is quite lacking; it probably just reflects the original work too much.

It would be better to have a regular conversation with a manga writer who is around.

I think they were a manga artist who deserved at least that much.

In the first place, this person was only in the dojo until they were matched with a foster parent, and I don’t think they practiced until they received a sword like the leader did.

>>120

I was trained in swordsmanship while I was taken in, but I wonder if I’m just naturally a monster or if the old man was really good at teaching.

Anime feels a bit rushed, doesn’t it?

The cave scene ends in one minute, and the appearance of Xenoblade is a bit much.

It was cute how Lisa and Dela got into the love stories inside the cave.

>>121

Anyway, I think they’re trying to rush through the original material at lightning speed and end it there, which is likely to crush the content of the comic adaptation.

I have no intention of making it popular.

>>136

Now that you mention it, there might be some truth to that.

I don’t really feel much affection for the works in anime.

>>158

It’s the same old story of crushing creators…

As an animator, I wonder if having the original work is better than a comic adaptation when it comes to making an anime.

You won’t have to be pulled in by the movements and direction of the comic adaptation version.

>>122

It’s because it’s an adaptation of the original work and not an adaptation of the comic, isn’t it?

>>122

I can’t draw, I’m sorry, let’s just say it honestly.

>>140

Seriously, low-budget anime in another world hardly moves…

It has already turned into a failure.

You have a convenient brain.

Since the original author has given permission, it’s fine, isn’t it?

It’s not something for outsiders to fuss over.

From what I can tell, I met them when they were around 5 to 6 years old, taught them swordsmanship for about three years, and then they were taken in by their adoptive parents in the royal capital.

It’s a reunion after 20 years, so our ages are, um…

A conflict is called that because the strengths are balanced.

The child who mastered all of the teacher’s swordsmanship is the Sword Magic user.

The moment it wasn’t an incredibly action-packed scene inspired by the comic in the first episode, I realized… (I see).

It seems like there’s a lot of commotion in the thread about giving cheese.

Original work is trash.

The anime is mediocre.

Good manga.

There are no people evaluating it other than that, and there isn’t any conflict or anything like that, right?

I thought that when there’s a manga, the anime adaptation would be based on the manga, like with the narou (web novel) anime.

Depending on the work, the character design can even be different.

The knight captain is cool, isn’t he?

The latest volume of the manga features an epic battle between the vice principal and the old man.

I feel like it’s a McCain.

Since we are closest in age, she seems to be a candidate for my wife, but we feel more like parent and child to each other.

Is that lower body insane?

Why are you still strangely trying to make your presence known even though we’ve only been together for that little amount of time…?

Is there a winning heroine first…?

Was he late to become a black man… my former disciple…

>>154

A girl who loves talking about love… a girl? Well, she’ll probably find a good person eventually.

They seem like decent people too.

I’m a sword saint, so I’m not a bloodline of genetically modified humans from the super empire…

In the case of “Tensei Slime,” the original notation in the opening credits lists the manga adaptation staff before the original author.

It is also referred to as a monthly Sirius serialization, so it is completely an anime adaptation of the manga.

>>156

If Akita had worked hard to get it animated, it would have been different.

The protagonist is an old man, to begin with.

What’s the age difference with the old man?

>>162

The old man is about 46… yeah.

I mean, if you think about it normally, the middle-aged guy from the previous term’s online shopping is probably tougher, right?

The original old man is at a level where he’s being too self-deprecating and it’s rude to those around him.

>>164

In that area, after the Hendricks fight in volume one of the manga, his lack of confidence made the good-natured young man become overly serious. Despite his lack of confidence, he sincerely tried his best to face the situation, which was handled well.

It tends to be thought of as old man × beautiful girl, but there’s no girl.

>>165

In other words, it’s not strange to marry anyone.

And there is a heroine who was the first to take care of and nurture them; I think they make a good match.

>>170

Well, I called you here to get married…

>>165

You are here, aren’t you?

It’s a youthful loli!

>>165

It’s coming out soon!!!!!!!

As the rounds go on, the action keeps becoming more subtle, and rather than being strong, it seems like the surroundings are getting weaker, so of course there will be complaints, right?

I’m too concerned about the ridiculous clothes.

>>168

The more serious the conversation gets, the more I notice the captain’s outfit.

I mean, in the past, the leader used to wear regular clothes too, right?

I wish they would calm down a bit and not release two spin-off comic adaptations at the same time…!

Can’t you even evaluate what you like without mocking something?

I think it’s difficult to understand an old man’s strength as much as in manga.

It might be around the part where they cut the straw dummy at the weapon shop or how to dodge the vice captain’s attacks.

It’s Higashiyama, the uncle killer.

I think if they had honestly adapted the manga into an anime, this miserable conflict wouldn’t have happened…

>>177

There are limitations to adapting the direction of the manga into the anime, so that’s tough too.

Scenes of reading each other.

I think the protagonist’s voice is nice.

Well, the manga adaptation is pretty tough too, right?

It must be a work that enjoys that tightness.

The original work works because it’s in the first person, and the manga changed that because it couldn’t do so, but the anime just went ahead without thinking, and that’s the result.

Once it gets colored, the captain seriously becomes a pervert…

The girl eventually comes out later and becomes a daughter.

Looking at the ending, they do look quite grown up.

>>183

That’s the result of their own hard work…

Being told to knock it off by the neighbor is quite something.

Manga allows you to adjust the speed yourself.

If you don’t understand the differences between the media of anime and manga

Your pants are showing.

The area around the crotch is worse than an ordinary angle that is painfully high-cut.

I had the impression that the disciples were in love with his character because they were raised together until they became full-fledged, but it seems their time together varies quite a bit.

A design that has been calculated to determine how things can become worse.

×Original work

◯Draft

If I make a move on that girl, wouldn’t that be quite a situation…?

In Hollywood movies, there are countless unspectacular middle-aged men who are actually former elite special forces, and in these mixed-up setups, they end up being adored by young women.

Why is it that the thread image is unusually criticized so harshly?

>>199

Isn’t it your personality?

>>199

The knowledge of Narou readers is narrow.

As narrow as Kagawa Prefecture.

>>208

It’s just a bit disappointing to not even reach the level of a nameless one forever…

>>199

It’s all in how you present it.

It’s not that there aren’t tough things in Hollywood either.

>>201

I guess the only one aiming for it is the captain.

>>201

You’re the only one who’s showing that kind of affection to the old man, right, leader?!

You look best as an old woman.

When you list it out, it seems like a sword-fighting business, but the characters’ creepiness and the script that just praises the old man feels like a backdrop or a stage set…

It’s hard to understand in black and white manga, but…

It must be really strange in anime, for sure.

It’s better than being turned into a worthless character that’s different from both the original story and the manga by a corrupt lord.

I’m not sure if they will make it happen, but I think they realized that having a greater age difference than Kenshin and Kaoru is not good.

Kuruni also has her breasts exposed, so it’s amazing.

I want the loli grandma to show her original adult form soon.

I wonder who they’re saying is creepy.

I think the leader’s sexual desire is gross, but…

Naobou is playing a character in a strange outfit again.

You must be around the same age as Misato Katsuragi used to be.

You can do it!

Are you targeting someone other than the leader?

In a sense, business as usual.

The manga version depicts the sword techniques and their portrayal at a very high level…

I’ve been told by my father to find a wife, just to let you know.

The teacher I’m really concerned about has no romantic feelings for anyone at all.

It’s amazing to be at this angle even though I’m not brainwashed.