Home » Cinderella Gray » [Cinderella Gray] Will there be any Uma Musume manga that hits as hard as Shingrey in the future?

[Cinderella Gray] Will there be any Uma Musume manga that hits as hard as Shingrey in the future?

Otaku Review Image

Uma Musume Cinderella Gray

1: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:18

So, you want to have a lot of rivals appear and end with a grand finale, right?
Is it another horse… Stay Gold…?

2: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:19Yeahx27

The subject of Oguri is too strong.

3: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:19Yeahx3

Even if Ito Pierre, Hisakumi, and the three of them teamed up, I don’t think there is any subject that surpasses Oguri Cap.

4: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:20Yeahx9

Stay Gold is mostly full of dark stories except for the last one, so it’s tough for a long manga.

5: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:20Yeahx1

>>4Because rivals show their momentary brilliance and then scatter each time.

11: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:25

>>4Instead of making it the main character, it seems like it would be better to place it in a position to continue watching an ensemble drama and finally do the Stay Gold arc in the last run.
Dubai will be sacrificed, but…

87: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:53

>>11Just to be sure, I’m also going together with To The Victory and Eagle Cafe…

6: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:22

It’s already tough to meet the condition of a famous horse leaving with a splendid result.

7: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:22

I thought my rival was my goal, but to have them break down right in front of me… is that really a story that spans 20 volumes?

8: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:23

It can be frustrating if the main character keeps losing.
If you keep winning all the time, it can also be quite annoying.
I prefer someone whose record is moderately winning with occasional losses.

9: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:23

I did non-pretty things too.
The middle way was done in the anime.
I have done casual ones a few times.
There are gourmet variations of change-ups too.
What else can I do?

10: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:25

It looks like cooking Orpheus and some other things might be difficult, but I wonder if there’s a way to manage it.
It’s generally assumed that permission will be obtained.

12: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:26

If the original work isn’t strong, it won’t do, so winning too much or losing too much is not acceptable.

13: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:28Yeahx9

I feel it’s better to do standalone episodes in the direction of the hoofprints of the noble horses rather than attempting a long series poorly.

14: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:28Yeahx2

If we’re going to do something with Stay Gold, I think it should be a movie.

15: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:29

Let’s choose from here.
Let's choose from here.

“`
4 wins 85 Oguri Cap, male 32 races 22 wins 4 wins 12 wins 0 wins turf dirt 16-24 1264 pts 95 Special Week, male 17 races 10 wins 4 wins 9 wins 0 wins turf dirt 20-28 1121 pts 87 Mejiro McQueen, male 21 races 12 wins 4 wins 9 wins 0 wins turf 22-30 1118 pts 03 Meisho Samson, male 27 races 9 wins 4 wins 6 wins 0 wins turf dirt 20-28 1037 pts 14 Lis Grace, female 22 races 7 wins 3 wins 5 wins 1 win turf dirt 16-24 981 pts 16 Chrono Genesis, female 17 races 8 wins 4 wins 6 wins 0 wins turf dirt 16-24 965 pts 99 Symboli Kris S, male 15 races 8 wins 4 wins 6 wins 0 wins turf dirt 20-24 916 pts 97 Eishin Preston, male 32 races 10 wins 4 wins 5 wins 3 wins turf dirt 16-20 904 pts 16 Loves Only You, female 16 races 8 wins 1 win 2 wins 3 wins turf dirt 18-22 817 pts 92 Mayano Top Gun, male 21 races 8 wins 4 wins 5 wins 0 wins turf dirt 22-30 803 pts 04 Daiwa Scarlet, female 12 races 8 wins 4 wins 6 wins 0 wins turf dirt 16-24 795 pts 95 Grass Wonder, male 15 races 9 wins 4 wins 7 wins 0 wins turf dirt 16-24 744 pts 88 Tokai Teio, male 12 races 9 wins 4 wins 8 wins 0 wins turf dirt 20-24 734 pts 15 Lucky Lilac, female 19 races 7 wins 4 wins 6 wins 4 wins turf dirt 18-22 719 pts 80 Mr. CB, male 15 races 8 wins 4 wins 6 wins 0 wins turf dirt 18-26 716 pts 20 Liberty Island, female 10 races 5 wins 4 wins 5 wins 0 wins turf dirt 16-24 585 pts
“`

16: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:30

If you’re going to do something with Stego, it’s better to do it in the last year so it doesn’t get boring.
After that, it can also be connected to the story of Dorijia Orufe.

17: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:31

I wish Dou Deuce could participate in the last Arima.

24: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:34

>>17Well, if it ends with Equinox waiting in a race that feels like Arima, it might just work out…

110: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:59

>>24Cliffhanger ED at the underground horse path of the Dream Winter Trophy.

18: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:32

If the original work’s achievements are suitable for a shounen manga protagonist, then it’s Mayano Top Gun.

120: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:01

>>18There will probably be a spotlight on Stubro, but I wonder when that will be…

19: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:32

I want to hear about the legends who probably won’t be able to come to the training anymore.
High Seiko and so on.

20: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:33

It seems that Oguri and Teio, who were said to be like manga protagonists, hit the jackpot twice, so it might be difficult for any other work to achieve such a wide success.
As long as you slowly unfold a decent story from there.

21: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:33

If allowed, it would be good to depict recent racehorses.
You can turn the hot new racing demographic you’ve captured into fans.

27: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:35

>>21Here it comes… Dou Deuce.

22: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:34

Deep Impact… the ending is just too intense.

29: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:36Yeahx3

>>22It’s boring because all we do is win.
I thought it was unbeatable, but then I lost and was finished off at the Arc de Triomphe.

23: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:34

I hit a movie with Jungle Pocket, and the subject matter seems flexible.

26: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:35Yeahx3

>>23It’s different when it comes to manga, even if it’s the same for movies.

28: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:36Yeahx1

>>23It often depends on the dish and the seasoning, right?
It seems difficult to avoid monotony while releasing good works consecutively, but I hope you try various things.

25: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:35

In the case of Oguri, it’s less about the race results or the finish.
The drama is strongest as a young warrior from the countryside faces a succession of well-matched rivals.
No matter how decent the numbers are, if that part is weak, it won’t get exciting.

30: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:37Yeahx3

Jumpoke is hard to touch because of that.

32: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:38

>>30You made a movie!?

34: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:39Yeahx2

>>32Since we’ve already done the movie, there’s no need to do that again.

39: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:40

>>34Now I’m a Baumkuchen shop.
I saw a relatively unknown discount when I went shopping.

48: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:43Yeahx9

>>30It’s completely unnecessary to force it into a controversial topic just because it’s a stage name inspired by a racehorse like Jungle Pocket.

71: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:49Yeahx2

>>48It’s wrong to treat something that isn’t bad in the first place as a controversial topic.
In fact, since it’s a wrongful accusation, the official decision is not to replace it even if the movie is distributed.

31: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:38

Teioh’s miraculous comeback is evident even at the point where he is defeating strong competitors from around the world in the Japan Cup after a long absence.
The following year, they’re going to show me something even more amazing, so I’m really impressed…

33: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:39

Strong horses attract everyone’s attention and are popular, but when it comes to discussing them, the conversation tends to end with “they were strong,” so there’s not much to talk about.

108: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:58

>>33That’s not true; it will normally expand if the focus is on it.
If it’s going to be adapted into a comic, it would be better to end with a good aftertaste.

35: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:39

It might be difficult to surpass Oguri and Teio if we depict everything from debut to last run, so perhaps it would be better to pick up dramatic parts like RTTT and New Era.

38: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:40Yeahx2

>>35I think it’s best to tell stories that focus only on the dramatic aspects of various horses in a short format.
The original type of racehorse manga is like this, isn’t it?

49: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:43

>>38It seems like a Uma Musume version of the hoofprints of the champion horses.

55: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:44

>>49The hoofprints of the Uma Musume.

36: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:39Yeahx1

There are no horses that can surpass Oguri with just a single material.
If we were to depict TTG as an ensemble drama, perhaps… that’s where it would be.

47: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:43Yeahx4

>>36Rise from the countryside.
The tragedy caused by the rules.
Rivals who appear one after another, competing in wins and losses.
A sufficient number of races to compete against them fully.
Countless episodes resulting from becoming a social phenomenon.
After going through setbacks, it can end beautifully with a happy ending.
It has most of the elements I want for storytelling…

37: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:39

Even if you search the world, the only horse with a story that matches Oguri is probably Seabiscuit.

40: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:40Yeahx1

>>37I like Cody’s Wish.

41: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:40

With Shinzaan and Mihoshinzan, it seems we can talk about CB Ace Rudolf.

42: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:41

“Legend of the Gallant Horse Girls”

43: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:41

A classic with rivals of Equinox! And a thrilling consecutive 6-win advance starting from autumn!
I want to read that too, but it seems super difficult to depict it interestingly.

44: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:42

“Phantom Uma Musume”
Starring: Tazuna Shunkawa

45: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:42Yeahx4

However, I thought at first that Singre might not be able to go all the way, but before I knew it, we were at the end, and there are some deeply moving moments…

46: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:42

If Equinox is the main character, the first Autumn Sky becomes the peak as a manga, and after that, it suddenly starts to dominate.

51: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:44Yeahx1

Narita Top Road was truly ideal as a subject for a whole movie.

52: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:44

Tokai Teio has already been featured in an anime.

61: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:46

>>52Since I don’t know the real horse, I can’t help but feel that this costume might be cursed.

64: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:47

>>52As for the j.c. that was omitted because it overlaps with the first season, I would be satisfied if they do it somewhere else.

54: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:44

In the development scenario, I am strong. I won because I am strong, and it’s only natural to have a face that says so. Those who are flat and not interesting…
Since Uma Musume has a style that respects autonomy and individuality, when the Uma Musume characters are lost, they usually solve their problems themselves rather than the trainer stepping in to give them a pep talk and help them recover.

56: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:45

If you’re going to do Stay Gold, it should be the final chapter of the ensemble drama of the 97 generation, not just a standalone.

57: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:45

Movies can capture a brief range of time…

58: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:46

Ai, Lala, and Tact seem to be cast with the premise of being animated.

62: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:46

>>58Can you say the same thing after looking at Pokke and Dantz?

59: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:46

I personally think that Danon Kingly and others will become quite interesting.
Recently, I’ve been fighting quite a few mares that have appeared in large numbers.
Good fight → Injury → Comeback G1 victory!
There is a flow.

60: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:46

Are you going to do SS and EG?
In the end, it’s an SS going to Japan with an old man.

63: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:46

If it’s okay abroad, I’d like to see Tiznow.

65: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:47

>>63Are you planning to make Invazor the villain…?

66: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:47

The original work’s performance is not suited for Uma Musume, ranked 1st.
Vodka

73: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:50

>>66Emphasize the Gimlet and intensify the Derby father-daughter triumph.
Should we focus on the rivalry with Daiwa Scarlet and conclude with the intense showdown at the Autumn Ten?
It seems like the direction may diverge based on whether or not they continue to undertake overseas expeditions and fight against Company and Screen Heroes after Dasuka’s retirement.

162: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:09

>>73It feels like the discussion around Tiara Uma Musume is gradually being reinforced, so I can’t shake the feeling that she might eventually become the main character.

67: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:48

Cinderella Gray is based on racing and current events from that time, but the culture related to smartphones and such is set to modern standards to avoid making readers feel uneasy. However, I feel that this is actually causing confusion for some readers.

69: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:49Yeahx3

>>67?
I wonder if there are that many people who are watching thinking it’s a historical story…? It seems like only those who want to nitpick would be concerned about that.

79: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:52

>>67Because it would be unpleasant, right… if Kasamatsu were filled with cigarette butts and empty alcohol bottles…

68: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:48

In the Emperor’s Cup, let’s go with Turkin.

72: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:49Yeahx1

Looking at the example of Pokke, it’s possible to create a story even if the retirement match isn’t a winning match.
If there’s a hot race, there’s a chance for a comeback.

74: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:50

I hope to see WODAS get some spotlight someday.
When the time comes, leave the role of being in between to me, Pusu.

92: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:54

>>74The number of Wodas has been increasing too.
Regardless of vodka, I feel that if Dasuka is positioned as the main pillar, it could become overwhelmingly powerful.
It’s painful that Durijja lost to Dasuka even at Arima.

75: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:50

Winning in a retirement match is definitely very dramatic.

76: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:51

Katsuragi Ace and such…
JC is going to be super exciting!

77: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:51

Three cool anime.
Web Anime 1 and Movie 1
Two short animations
Manga featuring Oguri Cap, Laurel, Urara, Star Guess, and Anthology.
Let’s put Seiun Sky aside for now; is this about right?

264: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:31Yeahx3

>>77Although the medium is different, there is also something like Helios on stage.
Let’s set aside what to do about the performers for now; it seems like the stage can be set up nicely for short distances.

276: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:34

>>264The performance of the race scene using tap dance was quite challenging, but the length of the short mile distance and the timing of the dance matched perfectly.

78: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:51

It’s already been said, but isn’t the omnibus format the best?

82: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:53Yeahx3

>>78Isn’t there no one who can write that?
If possible, season 3 will be like that.

91: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:54

>>82It’s interesting how naively they think that no one will take care of them.
And it’s easier that way than making it a cool anime.

101: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:56Yeahx1

>>91It’s ridiculous and absurd to interpret that just because someone isn’t inside CyGames, they aren’t in the whole world.

173: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:10

>>82The anime staff suggested something similar, but was it CyGames that rejected it saying, “It’s primarily about Kitasan”?

190: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:14

>>173Making the invincible protagonist interesting is difficult, so they must have had a lot of confidence…

200: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:16

>>190There was a mention in the Umabako interview that the director seemed to have a hard time understanding the appeal of bloodlines, or maybe not.
Regardless of whether it’s true or not, I personally think that if the story about lineage had been integrated well, there would have been at least no feeling of it tapering off.

202: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:17

>>173There’s no such story.

211: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:20

>>202So where did what I saw come from…?
To be exact, I remember it was more like “in the second half, the perspective shifted to Kitasan as a rival.”

213: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:21Yeahx10

>>211Well, if you, the one who brought it up, have an unreliable source, then nobody will know.

216: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:21

>>211Unless it’s a screenshot, it’s just a lie.

85: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:53

>>78This looks the best.
I wonder how it is in terms of money.
I wonder if it’s easier to sell merchandise for series.

81: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:53

Do you want me to say NO?

83: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:53

I think that even if it’s interesting, a long-term omnibus manga won’t be a hit.

86: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:53

The JRA tried hard to create something that could surpass the story of Oguri Cap, but it was impossible.

88: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:53

If it’s High Seiko, it can go the same way, but the only rival is Take Hope.

99: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:56

>>88Since becoming an old horse, the last race was indeed the Takamatsu Kinen that Oguri won yesterday, and after that, it’s all losses. It seems difficult to have a strong finish.

126: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:02

>>99In the past, horses had many races, and I think those that ended their careers with the Takamatsu Kinen 🥇 → Kyoto Daishoten ④ → Open 🥈 → Arima Kinen 🥈 would run fast until their last race.
Since it’s before the introduction of the grading system and there are no specific race names for the open races, I wonder how it should be depicted.

179: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:12

>>99Takarazuka…

89: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:53

It’s my turn, called Special Week of the 21st century…

100: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:56

>>89Will the artwork by Sorachi Hideaki steal the spotlight?

90: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:54

If you base Haru Urara on historical facts, it’s no good because she won’t even come to the Central Training Center.

93: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:55

Gorushi is not bad, right?

94: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:55

I want to become an idol like Almond Eye, but if my trainer makes me run, I’ll end up winning a story like that.

97: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:56Yeahx4

>>94Almond Eye has developed a character that goes beyond being competitive and insists on winning, so that is…

95: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:55

I wonder if there will ever be a social game comic adaptation that can stand alongside Uma Musume?

96: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:55Yeahx1

Dasuka is, after all, a lifelong placings guy…

142: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:06

>>96It’s nice as a rival because I don’t have to feel the subtle emotions of thinking a competitor who seems to be competing for first place actually finished in fifth.

98: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:56

The Stubro is finally getting into gear and it’s really interesting right now…

104: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:57

>>98My sister is okay!

161: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:09

>>98It’s taking too long for the engine to start!
Well, given Laurel’s horse life, it can’t be helped…

102: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:56

It feels like Maya and grades are more suited for the protagonist, but it seems tough here since it looks like they’re definitely going to delve into Stabro.

103: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:57

There is drama in every aspect of winning and losing, which makes the story too powerful.

105: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:57

Isn’t the original author too much?

106: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:57

Wodasu can be a double protagonist system.

107: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:58Yeahx1

It seems that TTG could also do well.

182: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:12

>>107The orthodox idol Uma Musume, Tenma Tohshou Boy.
The Prince of Shooting Stars, Ten Point.
The late-coming green assassin, Greengrass (from Tenma Hayashi Village, Kamikita District, Aomori Prefecture).
The character stands out and is well balanced.

206: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:18

>>182The Uma Musume that Glass seems to admire.

109: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:59

I think if it were a manga, Kitasan Black would have turned out a little better…

111: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)07:59Yeahx1

Ikunox has various ways to win, and I think it looks great in manga.
Unfortunately, the small number of races and the fact that the latter half is consistently won makes it quite boring.
I’ve become a monster in the last two matches… if I can express that feeling well.

112: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:00Yeahx1

It’s really amusing how otaku, regardless of being anonymous, say that they can’t do it or that it’s difficult with their low level of creativity and imagination as amateurs… Do they think they’re professionals?

113: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:00

I want to watch horse racing anime.
It’s fine whether it’s a serious depiction of the blank era of the overlords or a light one in a 5-minute format.

114: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:00

I like the early part of Stabro where it talks about things like Sugar Nation and other non-winning classes, but it’s more for existing fans and not for newcomers.

115: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:00

If it’s the W protagonists of “Odouto 🌲,” it seems like it could be done.
That being said, it doesn’t seem very interesting.

116: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:00Yeahx4

It’s just too unpleasant to be a character who’s sulking for life despite winning.

117: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:00

Biko Pegasus confronting evil.

127: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:02

>>117Did you win…?

118: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:01

Honestly, if Laurel can make it, almost anyone can.
Personally, I would like to see something like the Yushun Theater mentioned above, but it would be tough since a lot of fake name mobs would be needed.

119: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:01

I would actually prefer to see Kita-chan drawn in detail in a manga rather than in an anime series…

136: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:04

>>119It’s easier to delve into the surrounding characters that way.
The fact that Shuval suddenly declared his love for Kitasan in the JC isn’t an issue related to Kitasan Black’s performance or anything like that.

121: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:01

Well, how about this? It might be difficult, but that’s what makes it interesting.
At this time, let’s put creativity aside.

122: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:02

Singre is spicy… Staburo, help me…

141: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:06Yeahx1

>>122Did you find it helpful with Stubro…?

153: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:08

>>141Help me…

155: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:08

>>122This guy… is dead…

123: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:02

I think a classic approach from the new era combined with older horses at G1 level is quite solid.

135: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:03

>>123It might be ideal to be able to approach it from various angles.
It would be great if we could somehow manage the difficulty of long-term serialization and the potential overlap in developments.

124: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:02

I want to read the Air Groove manga.

125: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:02

Let’s go with Hishi Miracle as the protagonist.

128: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:02

If it’s just classical, I want to see something like EFF.

129: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:03

It’s easier to get excited about late-blooming horses, but the beginning tends to be dark.

130: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:03

It might be nice to have a Taiki protagonist running a café with Dotou and the shop’s cat in a Kirara-style.

131: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:03

I think Meisei Opera is a talent that can take the lead.

132: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:03

I think it would have been more interesting if the short story focused on Kita-chan’s relationship with Daiya, with the Spring Heaven as the goal.

133: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:03Yeahx1

I think it really stands out in the story when Maya makes a dramatic victory by completely changing her running style beyond just simple race results.

134: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:03

You don’t have to focus on just one person.
I think the original story is interesting anytime and anywhere when it comes to a generational ensemble drama.

137: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:04

With Kitahara continuing, it’s a manga with Dusk as the main character.

146: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:06

>>137It’s Narita Top Road, isn’t it?

156: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:08

>>137If Kitahara continues, it will probably be someone like Believel Das Kabuena.
I feel like Kinkame’s active time was short.

138: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:04Yeahx7

It’s impossible to surpass Oguri.
The story is too well-made.

139: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:05

Long-running serialized manga is difficult, so let’s go for a short anime in the RTTT style.

140: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:05

Sales are too high.

143: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:06

I want to see a comic adaptation of Contrail that progresses like a mountain valley.

145: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:06

From here on, Staburo will continue to see Brian fall, right…?

149: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:07Yeahx1

>>145Don’t fall, Sun.

147: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:06

The second generation was sometimes said to have a heavy atmosphere until the characters were all gathered.

148: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:07

I think it’s ridiculous that, even though it’s only one season, too much time is being spent on unnecessary things, making the depiction of the main character Umamusume lack depth in the third season.
If they don’t get supplemented by the app, these new characters are almost all like, “Who are these guys…”

150: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:07

How about Rudolf?
Simply ending in a constant victory?

165: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:09

>>150They were originally treated as a boring horse because they won overwhelmingly too much.
It’s a horse that makes you want to talk about three defeats from the JRA and has their approval.

151: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:07Yeahx10

This isn’t a feeling thread for the last three seasons…

152: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:07

Rice and Rob Roy also have a strong protagonist vibe.

159: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:09

>>152She’s a plain girl with heels.

154: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:08

Why not just do the dirt group!

158: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:09

>>154It feels like it could be done through some kind of medium.

157: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:08

In the opera, there are about three more main characters I can create…

160: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:09

Not many old horses win their last race on dirt, right?
I wonder if it’s on the level of Rosita and Copano Ricky.

175: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:11

>>160Recently, there is Lemon Pop, but it’s true that there are few horses that won in their last run.
Perhaps it was because, not too long ago, there was little demand for stallions, and it became the norm for them to run until they decline.

163: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:09

Oguri doesn’t have any weakness in the first half, middle, and latter part; it’s really unfair…
In the spring of his fourth year, Inariwan comes rampaging in from the countryside.

164: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:09

I want you to do short distances or dirt next.

166: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:09

Stego is a good story when viewed with the goal in mind, but
When I think about whether it’ll get exciting if I do it properly from the start, hmm…

172: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:10Yeahx1

>>166I feel like it would be better to rush through it in a digest version like a theater film.

183: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:13

>>172I feel that the accumulation of a long period of not being able to win and battling through various generations might fade away.

184: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:13

>>172I wish I could have properly seen the digest part.

167: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:10

The conversation about anime and the conversation about manga are getting mixed up.

168: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:10

Before Oguri, it was an even darker era.
After Oguri, things are about to get exciting! But there are horses that continue to get injured just before that.

169: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:10

I think Digi-tan is quite good too.

170: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:10

If it’s around the Rudolf generation, I want to see an ace protagonist.

192: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:14

>>170First, we need to start by creating an atmosphere that Japanese horse racing is inferior to overseas racing; otherwise, it might be difficult to highlight how truly amazing Katsuragi Ace is…
I feel like the timeless vibe of the current Uma Musume makes it hard to create an atmosphere with characters that could fit into the future world.

193: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:14

>>170The rival…

198: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:15

>>170I want it to be done as a movie, not a manga!!!

171: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:10

The biggest problem with dirt racing is that the opponents become fixed with the usual members.

174: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:10

I want to see the autumn sky of Digi-tan.

176: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:11

Doudes is a rival who, despite being a genius type, manages to get back at his opponent on the biggest stage, but afterward, he gets pushed away and faces setbacks, which is full of elements typical of shonen manga.
The seasoning for the last run scheduled for Arima is quite difficult, isn’t it…

204: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:17

>>176It adds a pinch of the rivalry between Heart’s and Deep at JC.

218: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:22

>>176If you run it with modifications, there will definitely be people who will get really upset, but if you recreate the ending as in the original, it will end up being anticlimactic and will receive negative feedback from the general audience, which creates a dilemma.

177: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:12

I feel like it would have been easier for Digital to characterize a true hero route, but in the current direction, it seems like they’re not suited for doing mainstream anime and manga.

201: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:16

>>177Isn’t it a character design that’s impossible to make into a hero?

205: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:18

>>201In the first place, the growth scenario is just a story about going from an otaku to a hero.

308: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:43

>>201When the tone becomes serious, it’s a character that becomes proper, right?

178: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:12

I wonder if I could make a good manga out of Durandal, Believe, and Chokushin.

180: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:12

If they made an anime with Stego as the main character, it would be all about the Akanko Special as the main victory until about episode 8. What’s interesting about that?
It’s better to rush to Hong Kong in two hours in a movie.

181: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:12

When the protagonist has not been able to win for a long time and does not sprout, the period is when the protagonist is replaced, like Laurel and Narita Brian in Stabrō.

185: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:13

Viewers are extremely harsh towards a protagonist who doesn’t win, no matter what.

186: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:13

Oguri was incredibly popular in his first year after coming to the central region.
In the second year, I engage in fierce battles with new rivals.
In the final year, teaming up with a rival to create a miracle would definitely blow my mind if I were experiencing it in real-time back then.

187: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:13

Kitasan would be a great story if it includes Saburo Kitajima.
If you don’t do that much there, it leads to the strong horses being strong, so I think it wasn’t suitable as a story.

197: Japan Otaku Reviews25/06/09(Mon)08:15

>>187I feel that the story of Kitasa Black loses a bit of its tightness because the part where he was often underestimated despite winning with his father Black Tide is no longer there.

  • Related Posts

    • Manga
    • June 15, 2025
    • 175 views
    [Manga] The magic trick that everyone tried to master as kids but couldn’t is trending, lol.

    A conversation about magical powers and energy manipulation unfolds, blending childhood memories with dragon-human wisdom.

    Read more

    [Manga Time Kirara] Tell me your favorite couple in Kirara.

    A series of reviews highlights various anime and character pairings, discussing relationships and personal favorites.

    Read more

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    You Missed

    [Manga] The magic trick that everyone tried to master as kids but couldn’t is trending, lol.

    • June 15, 2025
    [Manga] The magic trick that everyone tried to master as kids but couldn’t is trending, lol.

    [Gundam GQuuuuuuX] Even though you’re a Newtype, you’re so insensitive, Egusabe-kun.

    • June 15, 2025
    [Gundam GQuuuuuuX] Even though you’re a Newtype, you’re so insensitive, Egusabe-kun.

    [Rune Factory] I’m sorry, but I live behind the general shrine.

    • June 15, 2025
    [Rune Factory] I’m sorry, but I live behind the general shrine.

    [Manga Time Kirara] Tell me your favorite couple in Kirara.

    • June 15, 2025
    [Manga Time Kirara] Tell me your favorite couple in Kirara.

    [Fullmetal Alchemist] I have no certainty, but I feel like Envy is the weakest among the homunculi.

    • June 14, 2025
    [Fullmetal Alchemist] I have no certainty, but I feel like Envy is the weakest among the homunculi.

    [Thunder thunder thunder] I thought this cover was sexy… so I bought it, and it turned out to be more interesting than I expected.

    • June 14, 2025
    [Thunder thunder thunder] I thought this cover was sexy… so I bought it, and it turned out to be more interesting than I expected.