Home » Anime » [Anime] The original and the anime are completely different, but both are masterpieces… I love works like that.

[Anime] The original and the anime are completely different, but both are masterpieces… I love works like that.

  • Anime
  • May 25, 2025
  • 0 Comments
Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)15:28Yeahx19

The picture in the thread is my favorite one.

1: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)15:29Yeahx7

The headband wasn’t so much, but Tanabe was quite different.

3: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)15:32Yeahx4

The original creator awakened to love after being pummeled by the anime side.

9: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)15:36Yeahx2

>>3In Vinland Saga, there’s a guy who keeps saying “I love you” and is told by his son that he’s being annoying.

4: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)15:33Yeahx1

I don’t understand what Tanabe in the manga is saying.
Because you shout about love without saying anything concrete.
I thought it was okay to make a comment about being shallow in anime.

5: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)15:33Yeahx10

The anime’s Hachi is amazing for being properly prepared before going to Jupiter!

6: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)15:34

Let’s play shiritori.

7: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)15:35Yeahx13

(This anime has a lot of original characters.)

8: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)15:35Yeahx3

The final episode’s short-haired boy is nice, isn’t he?

10: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)15:39

Tanabe was staring at the oxygen tank and thought, “Don’t be mean, okay?” lol

95: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:39Yeahx1

>>10Give me Gucci oxygen.

11: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)15:40Yeahx1

I wanted to see the story of Fee’s dad in the anime…

13: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)15:41

>>11Do you want to see an old man who looks like a nameless otter…?

15: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)15:44

>>13I cried a lot at the end of the continuing series of Fe and the two stray dogs’ journey…
It’s really great when dogs bark…

12: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)15:41Yeahx3

The first things that come to mind are Fullmetal Alchemist and Ghost in the Shell.

36: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)15:58

>>12I’m really looking forward to the anime being made based on the original work.

14: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)15:43

I wouldn’t say it’s absolutely true, but I also liked the Slayers anime.

19: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)15:47Yeahx2

>>14The Justice family is quite different.
Isn’t it completely different from TRY?

16: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)15:45

AKIRA is good!

55: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:11Yeahx2

>>16It’s great when the director presents crazy original manga themselves, just like Nausicaä…

17: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)15:46Yeahx5

I really love the original alchemy system in the first season of Fullmetal Alchemist.

18: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)15:46

Blackjack

20: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)15:48Yeahx1

Trigun is great, right?
Both anime are good.

21: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)15:49

I was surprised to see so many original characters from the Debris Division.

23: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)15:51Yeahx2

>>21I think I like the story of the dispatched prostitute putting in effort the most, quietly.

26: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)15:53

>>21The original work is mostly driven by Hachi, Koyasu, Fee, and Tanabe, four people in total.
The company Technoora itself is original content.

31: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)15:57Yeahx2

>>26Adding Deburi Combo + dispatched workers quickly gives off a corporate vibe.

46: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:04Yeahx1

>>26I feel like the name Techno-Ra appeared in manga as well.

50: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:06

>>46Teknora and Vega Corporation were there.

22: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)15:49

Mary of Purity

33: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)15:57Yeahx2

>>22I like both.

24: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)15:51

Since it’s different from the original work, what comes to mind is definitely Castle of Cagliostro.

25: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)15:53Yeahx1

Both the anime and manga of s-CRY-ed were great.
It’s not based on a manga, but…

29: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)15:55

>>25I thought there was no final boss! But there are mob characters, right?

32: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)15:57

>>29In the bonus page of the final volume, there’s a glimpse of the young Makoto of Leviathan trying to chase away Ryo-ohki.

30: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)15:56

>>25Both are scripts by Kuroda, so you could say they are the same.
Anime is more serious than…
The manga was wild.

27: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)15:54

There’s no pair of bosses around either.

28: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)15:55

The original work doesn’t have aspects of a work-related manga.

34: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)15:57

Relatively deep divides between the original story fans and the anime fans.
Tanabe is cuter in the anime.

35: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)15:58Yeahx2

I felt like there were quite a few original anime elements in The Tatami Galaxy.

42: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:02Yeahx2

>>35There are only four original works, so it’s mostly original content, but the way they interpreted and restructured the story was really amazing.
I often thought about how to make it a story of friendship with Ozu.

37: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)15:59

I think Kiteretsu Daihyakka is a bundle of original anime.

38: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)15:59

The melody of oblivion has a totally different atmosphere in the anime and the manga, but I like both.

39: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:00

The first episode of the original Planetes starts with a story about Koyasu’s wife’s space shuttle accident, so if you read it, you might be a bit surprised that Hachimaki isn’t the main character.

40: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:00Yeahx3

Harebuta

100: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:43

>>40If we have to adapt the original work of an anime movie into a series that airs for about a year, we have no choice but to dilute it like a weak version of Calpis…
This Calpis has turned into a Calpis-flavored whiskey or sweet potato shochu!!

41: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:01

I like both, but after reading the original work following the anime, I was surprised to suddenly awaken to something resembling religion or philosophy…
Well, I don’t think it’s wrong because it’s also an important theme…

43: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:02Yeahx2

K-On! has a strange feeling of being largely true to the original story, yet not quite the same as the original.

48: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:05

>>43Director Yamada’s talent has exploded.

44: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:03

Entering the Jovian route has been quite sluggish, but there’s still the “Goodbye Jupiter!” part, so the anime’s abruptness is undeniable.

45: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:04

The existence of a magical transformation of the failed project of Little Red Riding Hood Chacha’s Magical Princess.
I was stunned to learn that it doesn’t exist in the original work.

47: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:04Yeahx8

Considering the era of the image, the consistency of the animation is quite impressive.

51: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:07Yeahx4

A headband thrown out into space suffers from spatial dislocation syndrome and is about to lose its EVA qualification, but when it touches the engine of the under-construction Von Braun, it awakens, only to lose its humanity and become unable to love anything but space, and on top of that, becomes impotent. I wonder if people who only watch anime would believe this.

52: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:07

Starting to do things differently from the original is a necessary process for an anime director to succeed…

69: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:20Yeahx2

>>52To establish it as a single anime work, it seems that for better or worse, it needs to be somewhat modified.
There were times when we had to animate even when there was hardly any original material due to issues like timing and differences in media.

53: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:10

Tanabe, who was afraid of becoming someone who loses interest in various things as a result of awakening to love and becoming a depression patient itself.

54: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:10Yeahx1

I liked the self-deprecating four-panel comic that said, “Even though I’m the original creator, I can’t draw the face of the original character from the anime.”

56: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:11

I understand that people expect anime adaptations to follow the original work.
It might be because of the thread image that I like it when it’s completely different.

57: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:12Yeahx2

Give me air.

58: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:13

I like the first season of Fullmetal Alchemist.
I also like the original work.

59: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:13

I hope this becomes something completely different, like Fullmetal Alchemist.

60: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:13

Even if the original work is short, there are pieces that are well-rounded and complete.
I feel like many things become transformed when adapted into anime.

61: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:13Yeahx2

The OPED song is really good.

62: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:14

In the first place, there were only 4 volumes of the original work, and at the time of the broadcast, there should have only been about 3 volumes, but who was the idiot that said let’s do 2 cours?

68: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:19

>>62It was said that it was made with the money earned from SEED at that time.

70: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:21

>>68Thank you, SEED…

63: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:14

Oxygen deficiency syndrome… it used to be popular here, right?

64: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:16

Nausicaa… I prefer the anime version.

65: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:16

Give me some Gucci air.

66: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:17

Nausicaä believes that Director Kun will someday create a sequel.

73: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:21

>>66I have the desire for it to be done, but Anno-kun is also 65, and I have concerns about whether it can be wrapped up nicely while he is still alive.

67: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:17

Even if a fistfight suddenly breaks out in a company-themed anime of this era,
It’s surprising to see that it doesn’t become a problem at all when you look back.

72: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:21

>>67Why hasn’t that contract employee been fired for taking out security guards by the dozen in front of their boss’s boss?
I passed the full-time employee recruitment exam…

77: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:22Yeahx1

>>72It was outside of contract hours…

71: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:21Yeahx1

I’m not a lolicon, but I like the anime version of Kyoukaisenjou no Horizon, I’m not a lolicon though.

75: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:22

>>71The musical episode is great, isn’t it…

74: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:21Yeahx2

The voice of the headband was just perfect.

76: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:22Yeahx2

>>74The voice fits the character perfectly, doesn’t it?

113: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)17:01

>>76In Turn A, it felt like Bruno and the other supporting characters had a unique charm with their raspy voices.
I remember being happy to be in the lead role.
So Tanaka Kazunari has passed away…

78: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:23Yeahx2

Those fake ninjas are great, right? Huh… they’re dead…

80: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:24

>>78You fat bastard!!

84: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:26

>>80I couldn’t keep up with the trends, got excluded, wasn’t invited to work, and ended up surviving by selling my possessions… it’s so raw.
Even though I’m a ninja.

79: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:24

The chanting of taboo spells by the holy sword wielder is really nice, isn’t it?

81: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:25

Dynamic code, huh…

82: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:25

The voice of the locksmith fits perfectly with Truhniht’s dubiousness again.

83: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:25Yeahx1

I like both Ajin.
I think it’s good that Player 2 is available.

85: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:27Yeahx2

If it’s a work that’s very different from the original but still a good piece, then maybe the old Fullmetal Alchemist?

89: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:30

>>85A host club featuring Renge-chan.
I’ve heard that the treatment has changed after being adapted into an anime from the original work.

94: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:36Yeahx1

>>85Homunculus is born as a reaction to人体錬成 (human transmutation).
When I see the corpse of the person who inspired my model, I freeze and become unable to move.
Envy is a homunculus created by Hohenheim’s son and is a being similar to the step-brother of the Elric brothers.
I liked this original setting from the anime more than the original work.

99: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:41

>>94It’s nice that the last character is the homunculus of Scar’s brother’s lover… In the original story, Lust exits quite early, but in the old anime, she survives until quite late in the series.

86: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:27

I wish I could have seen the ZOIDS manga until the end…

87: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:28

I like arpeggio.
I have the impression that anime like Ajin or Trigun, when they are based on original works, tend to differ quite a bit from the source material.

88: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:30

Isn’t it terrible that the ending of the anime becomes the reason for contracting space measles in the original story?

90: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:31Yeahx1

Because of this, Tanaka Kazunari is still one of my favorite voice actors.

91: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:32Yeahx1

Thanks to you.

92: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:35

I quite like the anime Gunparade after boldly removing the grand settings of the original work.

93: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:35

I forgot the reason, but I liked how Onee-san was getting a serious lecture from Koyasu-kun in the BD’s commentary.

96: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:40

“Mai-Otome has very different settings in the anime and the comic version, but I like each of them as separate entities.”
Making Mashiro the male daughter of the princess’s body double and having the protagonist confront the replicas that drastically changed the personalities of the Hime from the previous work, or something like that.

102: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:47

Twilight Maiden Amnesia!!

103: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:48Yeahx2

Recently, all of Satoru Taniguchi’s works have been really interesting.
It’s a bit disappointing after Geass…

104: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:50

It’s completely different, but if we talk about good works, then there’s also Little Red Riding Hood Cha-Cha.

105: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:50

Speaking of which, there was a collaboration with Geass.
It’s an illustration depicting Ruru and Hachimaki taking a commemorative photo together at the same location.

109: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:54

>>105Since Senba-san was also involved in the character design for Geass, that must be the connection.

106: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:52

Anime is easier to watch because they add original characters and make the story clearer.

107: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:52

It’s a drama, but it differs so much that I wonder if it even matches the original Shomuni.

108: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:54

The assistant manager’s fondness for Indians.

110: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:56

I was watching it and now I want to see Planetes again. I wonder if it’s available on a subscription service…

111: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)16:58

It’s great that space is completely silent.
My favorite is the direction during Gun Sword.

112: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)17:00

please save Yuri

114: Japan Otaku Reviews25/05/24(土)17:02

Yes… before I know it, the time to reminisce has come…

  • Related Posts

    [Gundam GQuuuuuuX] Even though you’re a Newtype, you’re so insensitive, Egusabe-kun.

    Discussion on “OMEGA PSYCOMMU” explores the complexity of Newtype abilities and their impact on character development.

    Read more

    [Apocalypse Hotel] I finally finished watching up to episode 10.

    Discussion highlights emotional storytelling and character evolution in anime, mixed with critiques on pacing and consumption.

    Read more

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    You Missed

    [Manga] The magic trick that everyone tried to master as kids but couldn’t is trending, lol.

    • June 15, 2025
    [Manga] The magic trick that everyone tried to master as kids but couldn’t is trending, lol.

    [Gundam GQuuuuuuX] Even though you’re a Newtype, you’re so insensitive, Egusabe-kun.

    • June 15, 2025
    [Gundam GQuuuuuuX] Even though you’re a Newtype, you’re so insensitive, Egusabe-kun.

    [Rune Factory] I’m sorry, but I live behind the general shrine.

    • June 15, 2025
    [Rune Factory] I’m sorry, but I live behind the general shrine.

    [Manga Time Kirara] Tell me your favorite couple in Kirara.

    • June 15, 2025
    [Manga Time Kirara] Tell me your favorite couple in Kirara.

    [Fullmetal Alchemist] I have no certainty, but I feel like Envy is the weakest among the homunculi.

    • June 14, 2025
    [Fullmetal Alchemist] I have no certainty, but I feel like Envy is the weakest among the homunculi.

    [Thunder thunder thunder] I thought this cover was sexy… so I bought it, and it turned out to be more interesting than I expected.

    • June 14, 2025
    [Thunder thunder thunder] I thought this cover was sexy… so I bought it, and it turned out to be more interesting than I expected.