Home » Manga » [Samurai 8] The scene became a watershed moment.

[Samurai 8] The scene became a watershed moment.

Actually, I secretly had a set of katsudon and udon! Then suddenly, it got better!

1: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx41

A protagonist that is unlikable is simply not good.

2: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx24

On the contrary, I was in a wait-and-see state until the thread image came, so I felt that the adjustment for major authors on the reader’s side is impressive.

3: Japan Otaku Reviews

It’s a shift.

4: Japan Otaku Reviews

Half of it is right.

My ear hurts.

5: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx27

It feels like it was already decided before this point.

Rather, wasn’t it a straight path of mediocrity from beginning to end without any turning points?

6: Japan Otaku Reviews

I have lost my wealth…

7: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx10

Naruto had quite a bit of control over the editing.

Editing is truly great.

9: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx8

It was like being at NARUTO level 100 when things go wrong…

12: Japan Otaku Reviews

You’ve lost trust…

14: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx15

Actually, I secretly added a “Yeah” to my own response!

15: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx7

I love that it has become a crappy manga that gets criticized instead of just being a crappy manga that gets mocked and laughed at with eight hits and eight combos in real-time.

16: Japan Otaku Reviews

In Naruto, towards the end, there was a story about Kaguya coming from space and all that.

Could it be that Sam 8 is in the same world…?

17: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx7

Naruto was too much of a brat in the early episodes, and if the story had progressed without them properly maturing, it would inevitably lead to this situation, which is frustrating to accept.

18: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx6

Shimabu wasn’t good either, and even if something has a track record, if it’s boring, it’s just boring.

19: Japan Otaku Reviews

The protagonist’s personality and sense of ethics are like that…

20: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx15

It was so extreme that there were theories saying it was a fake.

21: Japan Otaku Reviews

At the point of the introduction like in episode 1 of Sword Master Yamato, it was still being able to be deceived.

22: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx2

It was revealed just before that there is someone who looks exactly like the protagonist.

The protagonist is exhibiting unnatural behavior and even changing their outfit.

Is it really possible that after all this, there’s been no change…?

23: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx8

I think it’s a decisive blow, but is it really a watershed moment?

24: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx4

It was hard to read from the beginning and unnecessarily confusing.

At first, there was a sense of “it might become interesting eventually if I understand it…”

While discussing the meanings of terms and such, I was waiting while making jokes about Ata Hachi.

When I went to space, Katsu Hachi came.

25: Japan Otaku Reviews

A work that could surpass Naruto if it goes smoothly.

26: Japan Otaku Reviews

I thought Neko Hachi would impose sanctions.

I was just passed by normally.

27: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx2

It was written in the rice ball manga that “the real deal starts after going into space.”

Even if the beginning was boring, it dropped readers who endured into despair—the first episode of Katsu Hachi from the universe.

29: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx2

I can understand that Hara Hachi gets mad when he is looked at with the same eyes as his older brother, but I don’t get why Katsu Hachi is just being a princess bully…

30: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx2

Did you take off the lid?

31: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx11

Making a woman request for cooking and sending her to do the shopping while you eat out is a form of bullying by a mother-in-law from the Showa era…

32: Japan Otaku Reviews

Continuing to advertise this and push for a fifth volume feels like the act of trying to warm an unfertilized egg.

33: Japan Otaku Reviews

It seems that the person in charge of the drawing doesn’t understand the interesting aspects.

34: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx3

The incredibly popular protagonist, whose name is… Hachimaru!

A little reckless, but I’ll do it for my parents!

Now, he is the most pure protagonist.

Readers are moved by that brave appearance…!

36: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx10

If you’re going to get yelled at like crazy and reflect on it, then that makes sense, but…

For some reason, the conversation keeps progressing without that, so I have no idea what Kishi Hachi is thinking.

38: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx1

This is even more confusing because it’s being pointed out by Neko Hachi…

39: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx1

Just when I thought I had grown after overcoming my father’s death, why am I becoming even more immature right from the start?

40: Japan Otaku Reviews

What will happen to the samurai who lost the princess!?

41: Japan Otaku Reviews

There were quite a few nameless people who were given up on at Katsu Hachi…

42: Japan Otaku Reviews

(I see… it’s a fake!)

43: Japan Otaku Reviews

If this hadn’t happened, it would have been extended up to volume 8.

44: Japan Otaku Reviews

I was following my older brother’s back, not mine (striking a pose that feels imposing).

46: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx9

I can still understand having values from the Showa era, but…

In that case, the protagonist should show his manliness by saying, “No matter what happens, I’ll protect you.”

Why am I thinking about myself not being able to protect the princess from the beginning?

47: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx2

It’s definitely a way of twisting the story that nobody has seen before.

48: Japan Otaku Reviews

I was supposed to be becoming more and more of a fine young man.

Why does everyone cut it…? Why…?

49: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx6

Is the princess being targeted!? It’s more about thinking of oneself after losing; the protagonist is currently the purest they have ever been.

50: Japan Otaku Reviews

Thanks to this falling, the bolt continued.

I just wanted Naruto to end just as it was in my memories.

53: Japan Otaku Reviews

Was there no Bo-meets-girl element?

54: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx4

Naruto was also a brat at first, but he wouldn’t have done something like trampling on good intentions…

55: Japan Otaku Reviews

The lines are too cluttered, making it hard to follow.

It’s not just that the sense of ethics is off, but it makes me want to stop reading.

57: Japan Otaku Reviews

You were really criticized from episode 1, weren’t you?

58: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx8

Don’t describe immature things as pure.

60: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx1

Even though Naruto was a brat, the difference in likability is amazing.

61: Japan Otaku Reviews

Zaosaga and Sam 8

Which one should I choose?

62: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx6

Because Ann is a quiet type, she herself doesn’t rebel against insincere behaviors like Katsuhachi’s.

I always have to use characters like Nekohachi or external characters to prevent getting attention.

Overall, there’s really no push and pull in the relationship between these two, and it’s just so boring…

Hinata from NARUTO and Kishimoto might like quiet girls, but they are failing to fulfill the role of a heroine.

63: Japan Otaku Reviews

I can understand having a bit of a twisted personality due to a tragic situation, but the fundamental moral decay is evident.

64: Japan Otaku Reviews

In the end, Ann will also be told that she is like Hachimal.

65: Japan Otaku Reviews

NARUTO really did well, didn’t it?

66: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx1

I’m not just happy to have scored a point with a clever tactic during my training to become stronger.

68: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx5

It seems like they’re unilaterally taking advantage of a docile woman because Ann doesn’t resist…

69: Japan Otaku Reviews

Why is the princess the one who has to apologize…?

71: Japan Otaku Reviews

Up until here, it’s relatively just a normal piece of crap manga.

There were many parts that I enjoyed using as material for jokes.

From here, it has truly become a terrible manga.

The atmosphere of the thread has completely changed.

72: Japan Otaku Reviews

The “Living Shame Collaboration” got a bit exciting!

After that, Bakuhachi was called a liar.

73: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx3

Choosing a girl who resembles Hinata instead of Sakura for the heroine might be a kind of reflection by Naruto, but it’s tough if the heroine can’t make comments on the main brat when they take the spotlight in the story.

74: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx5

Naruto, Sasuke, and Sakura were equally bratty when they were together.

Sakura scolds Naruto for his pranks.

Naruto expresses his dissatisfaction with Sasuke’s selfish behavior.

Because adults seem to deal with Sakura lazily.

It’s important to properly show that “this is because of this character’s flaws.”

75: Japan Otaku Reviews

If it’s Naruto, they say a girl would prepare food for him.

Whether to continue waiting bravely while hiding my hunger.

I’ll at least go shopping together with you…

76: Japan Otaku Reviews

I think they wanted to depict this as a brat with the premise of growth.

I don’t think a 6-year-old would be able to gain a favorable impression from readers.

77: Japan Otaku Reviews

What’s terrible is that Hachimaru changed his appearance.

Just when I was trying to look a little more mature, this happened.

79: Japan Otaku Reviews

I’m so out of touch that I can’t even become a mood maker to set the atmosphere of the scene.

There’s a lack of the kind of proactivity that drives the conversation, often resulting in only speaking lines when prompted.

81: Japan Otaku Reviews

I don’t know how to put it, but there were a lot of annoying characters in this manga.

83: Japan Otaku Reviews

I guess the editing must have reined in some of Naruto’s pranks.

88: Japan Otaku Reviews

It’s fine for the character to be an unpleasant person, but it bothers me when the people around them don’t call them out and just go along with “they’re a good person.”

89: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx3

When Naruto was a kid, the people he went to eat with were Iruka-sensei and pervy sage.

Since it will be in a parental position, I feel like it’s okay to do some slightly annoying things.

When romantic relationships and master-servant relationships mix, insincerity stands out.

90: Japan Otaku Reviews

Naruto was orphaned at a very early stage.

It’s no surprise that the people of the village would harbor murderous intent around the middle (that said, the leaves are crap).

There’s information that if it’s Naruto, it’s good to have things done in a favorable way, but that’s just wishful thinking.

91: Japan Otaku Reviews

A scene where Naruto stabs his hand with a kunai and says he’s going to continue the mission!

It is precisely because we feel pain that it holds weight.

In the case of Hachimaru, his head gets cut off! But he won! Even if it’s played for laughs, I don’t really know how to feel while reading it.

92: Japan Otaku Reviews

As a result of further misaligning my already offbeat sense, I became unable to accept it.

It was fine as long as it was done naturally.

93: Japan Otaku Reviews

On the contrary, in Naruto’s case, the pervy sage tells you to go buy food.

When you think about it carefully, there was probably an intention to make the master-disciple relationship clear, wasn’t there, erotic sage?

When Hachimaru went shopping around here, it was tough because Neko Hachi wasted his savings and collected a lot of hate.

94: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx5

What is that…?

The star where you were.

Mom…

I made it in time.

I really can’t stand the combo.

96: Japan Otaku Reviews

The start of this manga’s serialization is perhaps synonymous with having already crossed the Rubicon.

97: Japan Otaku Reviews

Sneaking

98: Japan Otaku Reviews

Since I only have a vague memory, I should reread everything properly during Golden Week.

99: Japan Otaku Reviews

The reason the perverted sage appeared was after Naruto understood that he was a brat.

I think they wanted to portray it with growth in mind, but they ended up generating more hate than savings.

100: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx5

To be honest, it was awkward even from the first page of the first episode…

104: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx5

A disrespectful theory emerged overseas that says, “The author died halfway through NARUTO and his brother is drawing it.”

105: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx2

The thread that was fairly relaxed with the standard format developed into a thread image.

The frequent serious replies still leave a deep impression on me.

I think it was the moment when the character Yamamaru died along with the work from a near-death state.

107: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx2

The peak moment was when I laughed at the very beginning of the setting explanation, which was straight out of a gag manga.

110: Japan Otaku Reviews

Some guy with dark skin was lecturing Hachimaru.

In the end, that sermon was kind of half-hearted, and it seemed like Hachimaru didn’t understand it either.

In the end, it’s just like, what was this episode where Ann just apologized and that was it?

112: Japan Otaku Reviews

But the twist is that it wasn’t Dragon Ball, it was Dragon Ball Radar… well, I like that.

I guess they intended to change the main character from the beginning.

113: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx1

The character’s personality and actions were awful, but there was also zero interestingness as a science fiction work.

Even though it’s a cyborg, it looks like clay, and it’s empty inside, so it splits open easily, which is really lame.

115: Japan Otaku Reviews

Can you say that?

No, this is really a piece of crap.

It’s the author of NARUTO.

116: Japan Otaku Reviews

I’m going to fly into space!

Whoa!

A depiction like that of a neighboring town.

118: Japan Otaku Reviews

Sneakily

119: Japan Otaku Reviews

The first page will incorporate a magnificent world view and intricate settings.

It’s the author of NARUTO!!

120: Japan Otaku Reviews

Summarize the events of how the Nine-Tails was sealed in the opening scene of Naruto episode 1.

Where did the method that pulls you into the world all at once go…?

121: Japan Otaku Reviews

The adjustment was just right for Naruto.

122: Japan Otaku Reviews

It’s terrible that the official stance is that those with bad personalities are stronger in the setting of the organization.

123: Japan Otaku Reviews

The people at the Jump editorial department who allowed that at the beginning probably just couldn’t take the reins, simply put.

125: Japan Otaku Reviews

What scene is the thread image from…?

126: Japan Otaku Reviews

Colony…

127: Japan Otaku Reviews

It seems like they are creating a game setting rather than a manga.

128: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx4

Know-how (the one that was completely rejected by the editors during the NARUTO era)

129: Japan Otaku Reviews

It was a gain to realize that even legendary serial writers who are considered world-class can still make mistakes.

132: Japan Otaku Reviews

Naruto has received a lot of criticism.

This is what happened when the seal was removed.

133: Japan Otaku Reviews

I promised to let them draw as they like, so I had no involvement in the edits.

Were you really hands-off? It would affect your next work if you tarnish your reputation, don’t you usually stop?

134: Japan Otaku Reviews

Skyrim-like tool tree

135: Japan Otaku Reviews

An excessively unreasonable frame.

137: Japan Otaku Reviews

It’s not uncommon for a hit author to mess up their next work.

It’s rare for an author of 250 million copies to mess up.

139: Japan Otaku Reviews

Why do I end up drawing Final Fantasy?

141: Japan Otaku Reviews

It’s a blockbuster hit that has sold over 200 million copies combined with the previous work.

Mind your mouth.

142: Japan Otaku Reviews

Kishimoto is one thing, but the editing was far too incompetent…

143: Japan Otaku Reviews

Was the gang manga that Marco was warming up to interesting?

144: Japan Otaku Reviews

When reading Red Hood, I notice that similar phrasing to that of Samurai 8 appears.

I think there are instances where Kishi Hachi surprisingly listened to Taguchi-kun’s opinions.

That said, it’s true that Kishi Hachi had gone strange.

145: Japan Otaku Reviews

Are you lecturing the author of Naruto about manga?

146: Japan Otaku Reviews

I think it was just bad timing that Nubohachi is no longer active as an editor.

149: Japan Otaku Reviews

It’s terrible that the protagonist has no cool aspects or relatable qualities at all.

150: Japan Otaku Reviews

The protagonist wears glasses and it’s kind of gross, isn’t it?

Not being able to relate at all is also a point.

151: Japan Otaku Reviews

The Minato one-shot that was released after this was too interesting.

I almost caught a cold due to the gap.

I can’t believe this was created by the same author!

155: Japan Otaku Reviews

A ninja is wearing a tracksuit.

The samurai is wearing glasses.

Even though it’s such a shift, it’s so different.

156: Japan Otaku Reviews

After using a big technique to defeat the boss last time, the exhausted and weak Hachi Hachi requested food.

While Ann is out buying ingredients, Happi is also out.

I don’t know, but I’m eating without permission and my body shape is going back to how it was, and I’m buying clothes without even thinking about it.

On top of that, I’ve been buying gifts for Ann with my master’s credit card without permission, and I’ve ended up getting ripped off, so the credit card gets stopped.

Isn’t it amazing?

157: Japan Otaku Reviews

Make it grow and succeed in becoming emotional with Naruto.

When I tried to do the same thing and did some kind of stress test, the work got ruined.

158: Japan Otaku Reviews

I’m not a warrior, I’m a samurai!

I am a ronin, you know…

159: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx1

It seems that the ability to draw interesting manga and the ability to analyze what is interesting are different things.

160: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx1

I read this first without reading Naruto, so I thought Naruto must be interesting, but it changed to wondering if it’s really interesting…?

161: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx2

The part around here, the state of being like a fidgeting mess was also quite uncomfortable, which isn’t very good.

162: Japan Otaku Reviews

This is just bad editing.

Do not neglect your duties.

163: Japan Otaku Reviews

Kishi Kage → Kishi Pachi

165: Japan Otaku Reviews

It felt like the true protagonist was ultimately Anne, so it seemed like a setup for a development like “Revenge on the scummy guy!”

168: Japan Otaku Reviews

It can be said that Kishimoto had bad luck with an unusually poor edit in recent years.

169: Japan Otaku Reviews

Well, it’s boring when the new series after the previous one ends is drawn too freely in a way that the creator just wants to draw whatever they like…

It’s a really common thing in manga from all over the world, so it’s frustrating.

171: Japan Otaku Reviews

In an interview, Oda was warned, “Don’t get too carried away, as the next work might not be as well-received as NARUTO,” and it was tough to see that same thing happening.

172: Japan Otaku Reviews

I feel like the beginning of Naruto also introduced the story of how the Nine-Tails was sealed in a narrative way.

I think that worked properly as the starting point of the conversation.

173: Japan Otaku Reviews

I wonder what the deal was with all the master characters feeling so slack.

176: Japan Otaku Reviews

SF and Samurai

Wow, that’s way too innovative!

(Gintama)

177: Japan Otaku Reviews

In the end, people who engage in creativity have a desire for self-expression, so everyone wants to create the ultimate story that they came up with.

There aren’t as many people who can do business 100% as one might think.

178: Japan Otaku Reviews

But the template remained here.

179: Japan Otaku Reviews

I think if it weren’t for that editor and the editorial director, a revised manga that received more input would have been published.

180: Japan Otaku Reviews

Honestly, I think it’s incredible that so many people are still following it just from watching that one episode, thanks to the previous installment’s influence.

181: Japan Otaku Reviews

Did Taguchi-kun leave the editorial department?

182: Japan Otaku Reviews

Was the scene of the transformation with the spine fully exposed some kind of fetish?

183: Japan Otaku Reviews

My eyes are slipping, slipping.

185: Japan Otaku Reviews

Someone from the past offered to show me the editing, but I declined.

187: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx1

Minato’s one-shot! Minato in a corner! The Tailed Beast Bomb of Four Tails and Five Tails! It’s an incredibly intense page right from the first page.

I realized that Minato, who overlaps with the final shadow rock, hasn’t lost his talent and ability at all, so he really is the type that shouldn’t be allowed too much freedom…

188: Japan Otaku Reviews

As a sci-fi samurai, it could have been even more interesting if it had a more vibrant visual style.

It’s kind of subtly leaning toward realism, wanting to stay grounded.

Even though you’re floating around so much.

189: Japan Otaku Reviews

I couldn’t like any of the characters in this manga.

Just because you’re a cyborg, isn’t it a bit too much to lose your humanity?

191: Japan Otaku Reviews

(Actually, I don’t know what kind of scene the original image is from.)

192: Japan Otaku Reviews

I stopped at around episode 2, but what kind of scene is the thread image?

194: Japan Otaku Reviews

That NARUTO has returned…!

A new era of the strongest dominion manga begins!

It’s funny how they’re marketing it like that.

195: Japan Otaku Reviews

A NARUTO fan was writing an article on their blog, but it was disorganized…

198: Japan Otaku Reviews

Why did they have the newcomer depict Kishimoto’s talent?

199: Japan Otaku Reviews

A character as shallow as Ann.

Kushina depicts the conflict of a woman in love and the position of the jinchuuriki.

I can’t believe this was produced by the same author.

200: Japan Otaku Reviews

It feels like they’ve managed to pack so much into a setting where characters don’t die even when decapitated, or where the blade of the sword is structurally separated.

201: Japan Otaku Reviews

The former person in charge must have said that for a reason, realizing subtly that the current editing team can’t control Kishi Hachi.

202: Japan Otaku Reviews

I wonder what Okubo-kun is doing now… Well, probably assisting…

203: Japan Otaku ReviewsYeahx1

It’s not dying, it’s disintegration.

“Die! No, I mean disintegrate! I think it’s nice that the expression has become softer.”

  • Related Posts

    [One-Punch Man] Void❤️

    The blog discusses character dynamics and relationships in a series, focusing on identity, themes, and emotional depth.

    Read more

    [Naruto] “If you say ‘If you direct malice, you lose'”

    Japan Otaku Reviews explores strategies in battles, highlighting themes of power, robots, and sibling dynamics in combat.

    Read more

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    You Missed

    [One-Punch Man] Void❤️

    • April 29, 2025
    [One-Punch Man] Void❤️

    [Princession Orchestra] I want to see a meteor soon.

    • April 29, 2025
    [Princession Orchestra] I want to see a meteor soon.

    [Naruto] “If you say ‘If you direct malice, you lose'”

    • April 29, 2025
    [Naruto] “If you say ‘If you direct malice, you lose'”

    [Jujutsu Kaisen] In the world of Jujutsu Kaisen, there are only cursed spirits and negative spiritual beings.

    • April 29, 2025
    [Jujutsu Kaisen] In the world of Jujutsu Kaisen, there are only cursed spirits and negative spiritual beings.

    [Kinnikuman] It’s a little late to ask, but why is this guy called Kinnikuman Super Phoenix instead of Kinnikuman Phoenix?

    • April 29, 2025
    [Kinnikuman] It’s a little late to ask, but why is this guy called Kinnikuman Super Phoenix instead of Kinnikuman Phoenix?

    [Ninja Slayer] Since the free period started, I’ve been reading it, but isn’t this really hard and tough?

    • April 29, 2025
    [Ninja Slayer] Since the free period started, I’ve been reading it, but isn’t this really hard and tough?