Isn’t Milli too strong?

I think it’s been said for a long time that the song has a certain impact.

It’s crazy that so many songs from Milim are ranking in the top 10 during the academic mass fever.

>>2

To be honest, considering the situation, the one that is most highly regarded as a song is probably “Mili.”

The next after the many new ones in the school mass is M.

Wasn’t Shani’s output last year quite low despite releasing a lot?

I mean, why are Shanimus P not voting for their own brand’s songs too much!?

>>9

Wasn’t there just too few Shani P who knew about this project?

I also found out about this project for the first time in this thread.

>>9

It’s not as if it hasn’t been advertised.

Don’t you read the announcements, Shanimus P?

>>25

Well, it’s just that there are only people who don’t vote like that, right?

Ah, this.

A few years ago, I saw someone who was extremely foul-mouthed.

I stopped watching it.

Ah, the final results of this project have come out.

It’s been going on for a long time, but it somehow has a traditionally strong military presence.

>>15

It looks like there are a lot of veterans who have been playing since the original, since it’s all cheerful and stuff…

Maybe the votes were divided because Shani has the most songs.

Since I viewed it as a cover, “Air on the G String” was the first to get eliminated from the options, but there are quite a few people who like to include it.

The dere songs are strangely low, but is it because the dere producer isn’t interested in anyone other than their own character?

>>19

It is probably so in part.

There are people who lament that there are few things to include because the person in charge often doesn’t sing, even though there are comments left on videos from the past.

>>21

I wonder if Shani feels that way for similar reasons…

Even if they have concurrent positions, it’s counted, so I don’t really understand where the focus lies, but it’s not that there are especially a lot of MILLIONLIVE producers.

>>20

Last year was certainly affected by the Miliani, but it seems to be distributed quite evenly overall.

I feel that regardless of this project, Dere’s songs are becoming less talked about year after year.

Viarra P made sure that the top 3 were all Viarra.

The reason why Millie’s anniversary songs are always high quality is probably because there are vocal variations for each member and there are many fans who support all of them.

In Deresute, more than 90% of the idols become irrelevant even for anniversary songs.

>>27

It’s not just about a simple preference for a song; there are definitely emotions and attachments that influence things like this.

If that happens, it’s only natural that everyone singing will become stronger.

It’s that time of year again, but there are too many Idolmaster songs.

I thought I was getting the anniversary song for Derest, but I’m not okay with the clear difference between the 5-member and 4-member groups.

It’s disappointing that the full version of Migratory Echoes and ECHOES01 were not eligible for voting.

It’s painful that both the Shanisong and Shanianime songs are all good, yet both flopped.

It seems that the people who are actually playing the game are voting, as the CM is stronger than FMW.

If you set aside the fact that military songs tend to become stronger, there are interesting data points that can be gathered, so it seems fun to use this as a topic to talk about favorite songs.

There are unexpected disparities in the male-to-female ratio and other aspects.

>>38

There is an energetic image associated with the voting project.

They were also active at the recent TAAF.

Composite brand? Since it’s a project that crosses teams, I didn’t focus too much on the game itself.

Mekurume, I think I put it around the unfinished Polaris.

It feels like there are a lot of people who continue from 765 to Mill who are generally fond of the Idolmaster itself.

Niconico, huh…

Shani P doesn’t use Nico Nico, so it’s understandable.

>>41

It feels like there are actually more Shani songs going viral with weird parodies on Nico Nico than I thought…

I would like you to try doing a brand-specific vote as well.

To be honest, the only ones properly developing are Makoto and Million Live, while Derepa is shrinking and Shani is in that state.

>>45

Mili is way too amazing.

At the end, it will show what each producer voted for, but both ShaniP and DereP have the right number of people.

However, I haven’t really been voting for my own brand’s songs.

>>46

There are likely many P’s who have dual roles, so I can’t definitively say that it’s just one way.

That said, both Dere-P and Shani-P are voting properly.

The dere phase is over now…

The M songs are mostly voted for by only M Producers, yet they are managing to rank high.

In terms of music, it was probably quite active and thriving, coming right after Gaku, last year’s M.

>>50

It’s the 10th anniversary, after all.

It’s a bit lonely that Shani didn’t take off in anime and games, but as an individual, I’ve voted for a few songs, so I might not prioritize whether it ends up in a visible position as a result.

The dedicated producers of Dere and Shani are ignoring this project, but it means that the dedicated producer of Em is properly voting even if they’re not interested in other Mass.

>>51

I didn’t even know about this project in the first place, so ignoring it or anything wasn’t even an option…

If I had known, I would have voted properly…

Although the millions stand out, M is strong too in this project.

Since everyone can sing the full song in the game, it’s unlikely that the votes will be dispersed.

I have a strong impression that both Milli and M are powerful in voting systems.

Not limited to this, but also the official ones.

Personally, I thought there were many Shiny Colors fans who weren’t interested in other Idolmaster series, but it seems that’s not the case.

To put it bluntly, the number of plays on subscription services doesn’t match the sales of the songs.

It’s something you see as data within one of the many fan communities.

When I think back, the official mascot was born from the votes, isn’t it, Miri?

I haven’t liked many of Dere’s songs in the last year.

Although there may be fewer songs due to the reduction, I feel like the proportion of songs by people who have provided many tracks until now is decreasing.

Well, if it’s Niconico, will it get stronger by being close to the lineage of 765…?

>>63

But recently, what’s been gaining traction on NicoNico as videos is either Gakumasu or Shani, right?

M tends to be at a disadvantage due to the regulations, but it is definitely making its presence felt.

In terms of the voting system, songs that can gather a wide range of votes while also being likely to come in first are strong, so overall songs from Millimeter and M have an advantage.

The Campus Mode of GakuMas is in a sense the epitome of that.

>>66

It was disappointing that this year’s Shani’s overall song “Migratory Echoes” was excluded…

>>69

What about anime songs?

>>75

Tsubasa Gravity and Prism Flare both have the entire unit not singing…

>>75

Isn’t there a theme song for the anime?

>>75

Please provide the Japanese text you would like to have translated.

>>75

As mentioned in the comments, it was bad that it slipped.

765 and Millie don’t have much presence in the current Nico Nico either.

So it shouldn’t be that 765 Mill P is particularly high.

Whether a death man video goes viral or not depends on whether there are memes.

There really aren’t any death man memes like BBMB, Karin Goro, or shrimp, you know, million.

M’s songs just stick with you once they hit home.

Thinking about this project from previous years, several strong Shani songs were nominated in the upper ranks, so I believe the impact of last year’s Shani developments is significant this time as well…

>>72

I wish at least one of either Shanisong or Shanian would gain some popularity…

Based on past results, the overall songs of Shani should definitely be strong.

>>73

Last year, “Voice of the Stars” was ranked 33rd, so it’s not a big deal, I guess.

The Shiny Colors producer is probably tired.

I’m touching Dere and M, but I didn’t know there was something happening every year because I haven’t really touched NicoNico.

I know about things like Yuka Saito and the shrimp massage, but…

Derek has become an app that I only reinstall and log into when I hear rumors that a new character has been released.

>ID:TBLojJP2

I’m not interested, but I think it’s a project that puts in a lot of effort every year.

>ID:TBLojJP2

Are you an anti-DereShani?

>>101

It seems like they are only doing it because they are being paid attention to, but in reality, they don’t seem to have any interest in the actual Idolmaster itself…

>ID:TBLojJP2

I was a psychic.

For now, I’m interested, so I’ll watch the video.

>>92

It’s the type that takes screenshots and posts them whenever possible.

It’s so easy to understand that we can just move on with the conversation without any problems.

I didn’t know they were doing something like this…

It might be the ninth time.

https://www.nicovideo.jp/mylist/70533939?ref=androidapp_other

I’m actually surprised that there are specific brand-bashing posts other than those from the ID-less thread bugs.

I want to believe it’s my sister’s smartphone.

Wow!

I’ll post my favorite Shanimus song from last year.

ONE STAR

Hey, hey, hey

Shower of Light

I’ve never seen someone trying to stir things up by raising a little and lowering a lot.

If it’s Niconico, wouldn’t it be fine to decide based on the number of views?

For now, I want Deres to make the full version available for listening on a subscription service.

I can’t really do a big promotion in this cytube room either.

You’re doing something similar elsewhere, aren’t you?

There’s no way an ID would come out just from here.

Even though they’re releasing interesting songs like dere Chinese city pop, they seriously never come up in conversation…

It’s really painful that Dere doesn’t have a subscription.

The DereShani Producer has gone off to the Study Mass.

I feel like even DerPP hasn’t brought up songs that aren’t related to their chara.

Isn’t it that the most mentioned song at live events isn’t a Dengeki song, but Dance Dance Dance?

>>112

Since it’s recognized by other brands’ P, it’s probably easy to bring up in conversation.

However, the Star Master songs still lack recognition.

I really can’t speak in my own words, huh, it’s so clingy.

There aren’t really many solo songs, huh?

It’s too obvious to be saying “amazing amazing” without mentioning specific song titles.

Not just DereShani, everyone from SideM and MiliAS is going to the GakuMas.

>>117

M and Miri are still doing the school mush while properly voting for their own brand’s songs, which is the result…

It’s not really a brand rivalry battle or anything.

It’s sad that those who work hard to compile the data are toyed with by heartless people…

Everyone usually votes based on the songs they know, so trends will emerge.

It’s just that it’s not like the brands are competing with each other.

It’s been a while since I’ve seen such a simple psychic test.

I should have realized that there are many Shani P’s smiling at the shrimp dispute.

I like this project because I can discover good songs I didn’t know every time.

If you crush various things, it comes down to the fact that DereShani simply has weak songs.

It’s probably that all the people who are still stuck on NicoNico are fans of 765.

The number of users is less than Shanisong, you know.

>>126

I just want to connect the topic that Shanisong’s active lost to Mirishita.

I only think that I’m just giving high ratings to songs I think are good, regardless of the brand.

Last year’s dere songs, I really liked Watashi Otogi Bana Shi and Moratorium.

I went through the trouble of labeling the Militant poop-loving man as a troll, but continuing to say things like Deregaru Shuniga is pointless and defeats the purpose.

It used to be that Shani was strong…

>>133

It wasn’t like that.

It’s probably about as high as the sky.

>>133

I still think the Shani songs are good.

Especially, the Shanisong songs had a high quality.

There are people who have been ignoring others criticizing the Idolmaster for a long time, but overly react only to Millim.

>>137

In fact, even in a thread like this, the thread pig insists that they’re not a Mill P!

>>144

It seems like you’re saying that you’re not a mass P in the first place.

>>137

Before defending the person lifting the mill with poop on it, say something about the comments complaining about Dereshani.

>>148

Aren’t we just talking about how the voting results aren’t good?

They are being isolated.

Serves you right, lol.

Say your usual thing.

“Mill Die Man is rampaging!”

>>138

The usual Milinch doesn’t have the intelligence to lift up Milly while hitting Shani, so it’s different…

In 2023, the top 10 includes Million 8, SideM 1, and Koshikyō 1, so the voting demographic that consistently shows up every year is something that those who watch every year can understand.

The kids who weirdly treat it as a club are probably not following the videos properly.

It doesn’t seem to be isolated.

Well, I’ll probably meet darkness at the Tokyo performance, so it doesn’t really matter…

Until last year, Shani was normally among the top, so if we say that only the MilP are voting, then it means that this year’s ShaniMas is no longer enjoyable for the other MasP…

>>145

That’s true.

>>145

Last year’s Shani was 11th and this year it’s also 11th, so it’s the same.

What are you saying?

>>153

That’s not it…

Every year, there are people who complain that only Millie P votes for this project!

This year, it was just that guy who started the thread from the beginning.

I feel that being ranked 10th with a bouquet for a celebration is generally a high position.

>>154

I feel like the fact that this isn’t the full song is the reason why many things are being said about Shani.

>>159

The top tier of Million and M is Polaris and Suite, so it’s not an overall song.

>>149

When looking at the aggregated results, there are normally Shani P present.

The story goes that it was weak from the beginning.

After all, the person organizing it is a military producer.

>>158

It looks like the banner is of Ranko.

>>158

When I checked the media section, there were only screenshots from Dereshani Academy.

First of all, it’s not just the veteran 765 producers participating; younger producers, Shiny producers, and Deresute producers are properly taking part as well, so how do we explain the poor voting results?

>>161

I don’t know who you’re asking for an explanation, but in producer work, multiple answers are possible. For example, if you were a main producer and also held a position in Millishani, you could be counted as three people, one for each role.

There are many concurrent positions in the first place.

>>169

It’s only natural that there are many people with multiple roles since it’s a voting event for All Idolmaster.

>>169

Why does Mill have more votes while Shani-Dere has fewer in the concurrent positions?

>>173

Votes are hard to disperse.

Since this vote allows for about 10 songs to be voted on, songs that can fill the remaining slots tend to be strong, and songs that everyone sings together are likely to rank higher.

Perhaps it’s because there are few songs that can fit into the remaining slots in Deremas.

>>176

I don’t understand why we’re suddenly only talking about the overall song.

It seems that there is a difference in the number of songs ranked overall.

“Shani feels like this is about right, but Dere…”

>>163

Sometimes…?

At least watch the video before talking.

I’ve been making threads all day, so I should have about 60 minutes free, right?

Don’t you understand that any P can be included in other brand songs?

Well, it’s true that there are a lot of million-dollar projects.

>>172

Why is there such a big difference even though it’s only less than 100 people different from Dere?

>>172

So, it means that Mill P voted for Gaku instead of Shani or Dere.

>>172

I’m curious about the voting details of the 15 unproduced individuals…

>>172

Looking at the history of producers, there aren’t many who started from Gakumasu.

This might be specific to this project, but…

>>189

As expected, a newcomer wouldn’t know about the volunteer voting project.

Rather, it’s quite a lot.

For example, in this result, none of the songs from Deremas are in the top 10 of the voting destinations for Deremas P.

This isn’t just the votes from the Deremane P, but also from other mains who also touch on Dere, so these dual-role votes are treated as DereMaste P votes, which is why such results appear.

>>178

Does that mean that dere songs don’t resonate with concurrent P fans?

>>181

This is how it will turn out, isn’t it?

>>181

As mentioned above, many people in Deremas are the type who aren’t interested in events outside of their main character, so it’s easy for those with dual roles to feel the same way.

When it comes to deciding who to give the remaining 1pt slot to, it tends to go to a unit song from my other role, rather than a song from a character I’m not in charge of in Deremas.

>>191

DereP chooses their vote based on characters rather than the quality of the song…

>>191

Both “M” and “Mili” have received a lot of votes from Derе-P for songs other than the overall song.

It’s pitiful that if you pick a fight with all the brands because you aren’t being taken seriously as a single brand, you’ll just end up isolated.

There are as many as 15 KR people…

>>182

You can watch it on Amazon Prime, so I want more people to see it.

The producer is cute.

Only the cost-free votes are strong.

>>184

The sales of the expensive discs were strong too.

What in the world is KRP?

>>185

Isn’t it fine to have your favorite viewers there!?

Well, I think the current Dere doesn’t really ride the trends and lacks a certain catchy appeal.

There are some hits, but the songs that tend to come up in discussions about projects are usually old ones.

It might be difficult to reach the audience that is engaging in a shallow and broad manner because there are no subscriptions.

>>194

Current music isn’t on streaming services = it doesn’t exist, you know…

I just remembered, but I feel that the fact that Deredere has not lifted the subscription full is the most painful.